House debates Bills
Workplace Gender Equality Amendment (Setting Gender Equality Targets) Bill 2024; Second Reading
Colin Boyce Flynn, Liberal National Party
10:58 am
I rise to make a contribution to the Workplace Gender Equality Amendment (Setting Gender Equality Targets) Bill 2024. I'd like to start with an overview of what this bill actually does and what it hopes to achieve. The bill amends the Workplace Gender Equality Act 2012 to require employers who have 500 or more employees, inclusive of subsidiaries, to select and meet certain gender equality targets and to report on their progress to the Workplace Gender Equality Agency. The bill also provides the Minister for Women with new powers to set targets and specify the rules in relation to the selection of gender equality targets, via a legislative instrument. It provides that, where an employer has not met the selected gender equality targets or demonstrated improvements within the relevant period of three years, they will be considered to have failed to comply with their obligations under the act. Under the Workplace Gender Equality Procurement Principles, relevant employers seeking to supply goods and services to government at or above $80,000 must provide a certificate of compliance issued by the agency as part of the procurement process. Consequently, such employees would be unable to provide the compliance certificate. It implements recommendation 3.1a of the 2021 review of the Workplace Gender Equality Act, which was a review conducted under the Morrison government. Recommendation 3.1a adds:
… a new minimum standard to require relevant employers with 500 or more employees to commit to, achieve and report to the WGEA on measurable genuine targets to improve gender equality in their workplace against three of the six gender equality indicators.
The review made 10 recommendations to accelerate change for workplace gender equality. Both the previous Morrison government and the current government have committed to implementing the recommendations of the review.
This bill introduces new requirements for employers with 500 or more employees—designated 'relevant employers'—to commit to, achieve, or at a minimum provide on and report to the agency on measurable targets to progress gender equality in their workplace against the six gender equality indicators. The bill amends the definition of 'relevant employer' to explicitly include subsidiaries of parent companies with a 100 or more employees and clarifies that in a corporate structure a parent corporation is also taken to employ each of the employees of any of its subsidiaries.
The bill also introduces a new power for the minister to set targets and rules in relation to the selection of gender equality targets. The bill gives power to the minister to set out the category of target which can be selected and how many of the targets to select. The menu of targets will be set out in an instrument to the act and will offer a choice to relevant employers to select targets that are achievable for them within the three-year cycle. In practice, the cycle for the target scheme is intended to operate as follows: year zero is target selection, and employers publicly report their selection of three targets to achieve over the next three years; years 1 and 2, the employer lodges their public report as usual; and year 3, the employer lodges their public report and selects their next three targets, which will be compared to the year 2 reporting data. From the data submitted, it will be possible to see whether the employer has improved upon or achieved their targets, and the WGEA will assess their compliance.
Businesses with over 100 employees are already required to promote and improve gender equality in the workplace, including through the lodgement of annual reports containing certain information relating to GEIs. This information is contained in the Workplace Gender Equality Instrument 2023. This bill will only impose additional reporting requirements on businesses with over 500 employees. If an employer does not have a reasonable excuse for the failure to meet its obligations or demonstrate improvements within the relevant period, they are considered to have failed to comply with their obligations under the act. The WGEA may name the employee in their report to the minister, and the employer may not be able to participate in government procurement. Neither the bill nor the explanatory memorandum provide guidance on what would constitute a reasonable excuse.
There are some issues. The legislation will affect over 1,650 of Australia's largest companies b potentially precluding them from supplying goods and services to the Commonwealth government at or above $80,000 in the following essential areas: accommodation and food services; agriculture, forestry and fishing; construction; education and training; electricity, gas, water and waste services; financial and insurance services; health care and social assistance; manufacturing; mining; and several others. Major contractors that the government rely upon would be impacted by these changes.
The other thing this bill does is impose excessive ministerial powers, and the minister has also personal powers to set targets and rules of their own choosing by a legislative instrument with no scrutiny from impacted businesses. This creates the possibility of even more erroneous complication and burdens on business. The bill introduces substantial compliance requirements for businesses. Reporting requirements add red tape to the operation of Australia's largest corporations, driving down productivity in an economy that's already struggling under the compliance bill of the Albanese government's radical industrial relations and energy policies. Adding compliance burdens to businesses will also inevitably be inflationary, adding to the Albanese government's homegrown inflation crisis.
Large corporates are captured in this bill, but what will be government go for next? It is estimated that this bill will create a further compliance issue for over 1,650 of Australia's largest companies. Should the government want to go further, next in line are small and medium enterprises, who are struggling with significant red tape and compliance burdens under the Albanese government. Whilst no big businesses have declared any meaningful opposition to this bill, they will likely contribute to the committee process in early 2025.
I've got some issues with this bill. In my working career I spent many occasions working with women and working without women, and I have absolutely no qualms about women wanting to do anything they like. In fact, they should be paid equally to men. But the simple fact of the matter is that what we miss here is that we are not comparing apples with apples. Many women don't want to be CEOs of companies or take leadership roles. You cannot possibly compare women who are working in the childcare sector, as an example, to men who work in the construction industry. It's simply not the same thing. I've got no problems whatsoever with women wanting to be progressive and attain whatever career they want to, but the reality of it is that, everywhere that I have been, with whatever jobs I've done, women who participate get paid equally and the same as men do. Here we are in Canberra. We are all legislators. We are part of the parliament of Australia. All of us are on equal footing when it comes to being remunerated under terms and conditions in the workplace. Some of these things get forgotten in the whole process of where we're going with gender equality, equal pay and so forth.
I think this bill is providing another level of bureaucratic regime oversight or erroneous red tape that will actually achieve very little in the respect of what women actually want to do.
No comments