House debates Bills
Workplace Gender Equality Amendment (Setting Gender Equality Targets) Bill 2024; Second Reading
Zoe Daniel Goldstein, Independent
10:40 am
I thank the member for Wills for his comments, particularly in relation to involving men and boys in the process that we are trying to achieve, which is to keep women and girls safe. Of course, women in Goldstein and across the country want secure work and respect. This is what the Women's Economic Equality Taskforce found when it interviewed thousands of Australian women, and to achieve this we must, as a nation, advance gender equality in the workplace.
As it stands, we're still a long way off. Despite some progress in recent years, Australian women don't have economic equality. Australia ranks equal first for women's education but is much lower down the list for women's economic opportunity. Australian women are much less likely to work full-time than women in many other OECD countries. Gender segregation persists across the economy. Most casual workers are women. Women do most of the care work, which is generally low paying. In the early childhood education and care sector, for example, 92 per cent of workers are women. And there is a stubborn gender pay gap of 21.1 per cent.
The moral argument for gender equality in the workplace speaks for itself. Women and men should have a right to equal participation in work, and all employees should have access to equal opportunities in advancing their careers. It's simply the right thing to do, and it also makes really good economic sense. A broader talent pool creates a better environment for generating ideas and better decision-making, and this improves the bottom line.
But creating a culture that values diversity and equality doesn't just magically happen. Systemic barriers and attitudes that stop women from advancing their careers don't just disappear by themselves. This requires intervention. Targets provide a disciplined approach to drive change. They help focus attention on change and keep organisations on track to achieving that change.
Setting targets also creates competition between industry peers and makes very clear to any potential employee which businesses are creating an equal and respectful environment. Research by economist Dr Leonora Risse found that target setting for gender equality promotes accountability, transparency and organisational confidence.
The Workplace Gender Equality Amendment (Setting Gender Equality Targets) Bill 2024 amends the Workplace Gender Equality Act 2012 to improve gender equality in employment and in the workplace, and it does this by implementing the recommendations of the 2021 review into the act. The bill would require employers with 500 or more employees to commit to achieve, or at a minimum improve on, measurable genuine targets to improve gender equality in their workplaces and accelerate progress in closing the gender pay gap.
Employers will select at least three targets from the menu of targets which are aligned to the Workplace Gender Equality Agency's gender equality indicators. The targets include both numeric targets, such as reducing the gender pay gap and improving gender composition in roles or occupations, and action based targets, such as introducing a paid parental leave program or enhancing flexible work conditions. Employers will then have three years to improve on or achieve the targets. The selection of targets and the timeframe will give employers the flexibility to act in the areas that require the most attention in their workplaces.
I note that some in the business sector are concerned about large employers having to meet their targets to secure government contracts. Their concern is that it's an unnecessary additional requirement. It's important that business is supportive of and supported to participate in this. Systems change requires all of us to step into the process, and I strongly encourage government and business to work together to iron out any bumps. However, this information is already being captured and provided to WGEA, so it's not really an additional burden. It's about setting a target to work towards and providing a bit more rigour and structure around the information already being collected by businesses. I do believe that targets are needed so we all clearly know where we're trying to go.
This bill extends the work that WGEA is already doing to create equality in the workplace, including the publishing of gender pay gaps for private sector employers with more than 100 staff. The data, which covers almost 5,000 Australian companies, reveals wide gaps across all sectors. The latest annual employer census by WGEA shows female chief executives and heads of business are paid an average of $158,632 less than their male counterparts. Pay gap transparency is something I called for at the Jobs and Skills Summit in 2022, very soon after the last election. I did this because publishing employer pay gaps creates the transparency and accountability needed to close the gap more quickly. Piece by piece, the government is building towards gender equality in the workplace, but we must step up the pace. There is still a mountain of work to do, if women are to have the same rights and opportunities as men.
At the most basic level, we need to value the care economy and harness its potential. The care sector is undervalued because it's an area of the economy that we don't think of as being productive or about investment. This attitude is slowly changing and it must, for the sake of the country. It's not widely understood that the care economy is the largest single employer in Australia, with over 1.8 million people, 80 per cent of whom are women, currently working in care economy jobs. It's also our fastest-growing sector, as measured by job growth, by a long way.
Building from that, we must accelerate the steps towards a universal early childhood education and care system. The Productivity Commission report recommends three days of free or low-cost set-fee early childhood education and care by 2036. I agree that we should be working towards three days of free or low-cost ECEC as a first step, but this time line isn't nearly ambitious enough. This should be a legislated entitlement. Without it being legislated, the cost to parents will continue to skyrocket due to there being no limit on the out-of-pocket fees that providers can charge. Tinkering around the edges will not deliver the kinds of changes that we need to see to make ECEC accessible and affordable. We need to reshape the system.
As I keep saying in this place and elsewhere, accessible, affordable, high-quality early childhood education and care is a win for children, families, women and the economy. We must also take action to address the gender super gap. Leading up to retirement, the median superannuation balance for women is a third less than that of men. This translates to around $50,000 less, on average.
I'd like to finish with some bold leadership targets. Despite some progress in the last few years, women are still significantly underrepresented in leadership positions in the Australian workforce. Women make up just 22 per cent of CEOs, 37 per cent of key management personnel and 42 per cent of managers in Australia, according to 2023 figures from WGEA. The same figures show that 34 per cent of board members are women, while one-in-four boards have no women at all. It's what the agency calls 'seniority drop-off', where the proportion of women decreases as the level of management and responsibility increases. To address this, Chief Executive Women is advocating for all executive leadership teams to be comprised of 40 per cent women and 40 per cent men, with the remaining 20 per cent flexible to any gender: 40:40:20 by 2030. We need to be ambitious and embrace this target.
I read in a newspaper article last week that gender equality targets risk generating blowback among men who feel they're blamed for what's happened in the past. This view fails to recognise that inequality in the workplace is not just something from a bygone era; it continues today. Setting targets is not about apportioning blame. Targets are about addressing imbalances and creating fair workplaces for women and business to thrive, which will benefit all of us. The Goldstein community elected me on a platform of gender equality, and at every opportunity I will continue to work with the government to improve women's economic security and opportunities and, by extension, women's safety. It is appropriate to be debating this legislation amid the 16 Days of Activism against Gender-Based Violence. Setting gender equality targets in workplaces is another piece of this very important picture, and I commend this bill to the House.
No comments