I thank the member for her question, and I hope that she's told Joshua in her electorate that she voted against energy price relief. One assumes that will have occurred. If Joshua works and is a taxpayer, I hope that she's told him that she actually supports the old stage 3 tax cuts, because that's what the Leader of the Opposition said in February, not that long ago: 'Do we walk away from the principles of stage 3? Absolutely not.' I assume she told Joshua that, if he earns under $45,000, he shouldn't get a tax cut today.