Thank you, Mr Speaker. The question is indeed why! Why did those opposite vote against $1.5 billion of energy price relief? Why? Why did they? Why did the member for Cowper not tell Robert Withers that he voted against $1.5 billion of energy price relief? Why did those opposite oppose cheaper medicines?

Government members: Why?

Why did those opposite oppose cheaper child care?

Government members: Why?

Why did those opposite oppose an increase in the minimum wage?

Government members: Why?

Why aren't those opposite supporting an increase in aged care?

Government members: Why?

Why don't they support anything?

Government members: Why?

Why indeed, Mr Speaker!

Government members interjecting—