When it comes to penalty rates, imagine if Andrew had been working for Clean Event. Imagine if he had been getting, thanks to the great advocacy of the Leader of the Opposition—this champion of the working class, this hero of the people—$18 an hour instead of $50 under the award. But there was something else: payments to the union, not disclosed. The member for Isaacs says that they are all proud of the Leader of the Opposition's track record as a union—