I think it would be remiss of me to offer observations on the taxation arrangements of any particular individual or company. But, again, I remind the Deputy Leader of the Opposition that there was more than $1 billion of tax crackdown which the former government proposed but did not implement, which this government is now pushing ahead with, and which she and her colleagues are opposing. So when it comes to cracking down on tax avoidance members opposite have no principle, no consistency and no record.

Ms Macklin interjecting—