And time is tight. I would refer the member for Flinders to the questioning of the Treasury officials today in the senate estimates about these issues. I thought the questions were handled very well by the Treasury. I remind the member for Flinders that all of those estimates and projections are done independently by the Treasury. The government stands behind the budget and the figures contained in it for carbon price revenue, and the carbon price figures.

Proposed expenditure agreed to.

Broadband, Communications and the Digital Economy

Proposed expenditure $1,860,473,000