This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Fatima Payman WA, Australia's Voice
5:25 pm
As Australians, we have a right to be proud of our democratic institutions, which are amongst the best in the world. The Australian Electoral Commission, at arm's length from the government of the day, makes objective decisions about our electoral maps. In many countries, including so-called democracies like the United States, politicians and partisan organisations chop and change electoral districts to benefit themselves and disadvantage their opponents. We have a very high level of participation in our elections. Through preferential voting and, in the Senate, proportional representation, we have a parliament which, while not perfect in the manner of its election, is far more representative of the will of the Australian people than jurisdictions that still use first-past-the-post, like the UK.
We have a lot going for us, but there are some areas that we can and must do better in. During Senate estimates last year, I asked the AEC for details about how prisoners can go about having their voice heard in federal elections. Some of what they told me was quite concerning. At the federal election last year 9,700 votes were issued at prisons around the country, as were 400 postal votes, of which half were returned. Data from the ABS indicated that, on 30 June 2025, there were 46,998 adult prisoners in Australia. Even taking away the many prisoners who are ineligible to vote due to the length of their sentence, that still leaves tens of thousands of people who were entitled to vote under the Commonwealth Electoral Act but were unable to do so. Many prisoners who managed to vote did not have their vote counted. The informal voting rate in prisons, at nearly 11 per cent, was double the national average of 5.5 per cent, and in some prisons the informal voting rate was as high as 67 per cent.
While it is unjust that this is happening, it is a massive improvement in a relatively short amount of time. At the 2022 election, just 274 prisoners voted across Australia. That's just 0.6 per cent of Australia's prison population. While COVID had its role to play in 2022's low turnout, the game changer last year was the allowing of AEC mobile voting teams into prisons at scale for the first time. These teams, which are also tasked with visiting remote communities, hospitals and aged-care facilities, attended 82 correctional centres across the country in May last year. This was bolstered by enrolment drives in late 2024 and early 2025 in preparation for the federal election.
The further back we look, the worse things were. A man from New South Wales who was in prison during the 2016 election told SBS about his experience of voting in prison:
Nothing happened on election day. I was not called up to vote, nor was anyone else …
I asked the guards again and they said they had no idea about anything to do with the election. It was as if there was no election.
It was only at the end of the afternoon when we got locked back in that I was sure I would not be voting.
On 22 June 2006, an amendment to the Commonwealth Electoral Act made by the Howard government banned prisoners, no matter the length of their sentence, from voting. A year later, an Indigenous prisoner, Vickie Roach, challenged the constitutional validity of the law. The High Court found in Roach v Electoral Commissioner that the law was invalid because it ran contrary to sections 7 and 24 of our Constitution, which require all members of parliament to be directly elected by the people. The right to vote, as was the case before 2006, was restored to prisoners serving sentences of three years or less. It is clear that things have only gotten better for the democratic rights of prisoners in the last 20 years.
There is still more to do. Of the 47,000 prisoners in 2025, 17,000 were Indigenous. As a result, of the tens of thousands who missed out on voting at the 2025 election, thousands were Indigenous people. As I mentioned, the average informal voting rate for prisoners was nearly double the national average. I commend the AEC for their work in trying to ensure as many voices as possible are heard on election day and encourage them to keep working to give as many Australians as possible the opportunity to cast their vote.
Senate adjourned at 17:30