This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Committees

Environment and Communications References Committee; Report


Paul Scarr

Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party

4:01 pm

I rise to take note and make some comments in relation to the Environment and Communications References Committee National Cultural Policy Progress report. In this regard, can I first compliment the work that Senator Hanson-Young has undertaken with respect to protecting Australia's creative industries. A very important issue has emerged, and that is the extent to which AI tech giants are seeking to gain access to Australian creative works without entering into appropriate licensing arrangements with the owners of the intellectual property in those works. Last night was the fabulous ARIA Music Awards, and I congratulate all of the performers and participants. But the best way in which I can demonstrate my deep respect for those Australian artists, musicians and composers is to say this: I stand with Australian artists against any proposal to dilute your intellectual property rights. I stand with you.

Intellectual property and copyright are as much property rights as bricks and mortar. From my perspective, one of the philosophical fathers of the Liberal Party, and I'm a classical liberal, is John Locke. John Locke explained the importance of private property, and liberals have fought down the centuries for respect for private property. That must include intellectual property rights. If big AI tech wants access to the works of Australian artists—if AI wants to access the works of our musicians, our screenwriters, our authors, our artists and our photographers—then they should pay for it, pay for it, pay for it!

I see Senator Hanson-Young in the chamber, and I again compliment you, Senator Hanson-Young, on the work you've undertaken in this space. It is very important work. So I say to big AI: if you want to make use of the intellectual property of our creative artists, then negotiate with them. Enter into licence agreements with them, because we in this place should ensure that our creative artists have their livelihoods protected. That means protecting their intellectual property rights.

The intellectual property of Australians in whatever creative field is not AI's to take. As long as I serve in this place, I will stand steadfast against any proposal which undermines the intellectual property rights of our Australian artists. And I certainly will not agree to any proposal which makes Australia some sort of intellectual property badlands, where AI can come into our country and trample over the intellectual property rights of artists all over the world. This is absolutely outrageous. We in this Senate should be standing up and fighting to protect the rights of Australian creative artists, not entering into some dodgy backroom deal to dilute their property rights. It's absolutely outrageous, and I certainly will not stand for it.

I make this commitment: any proposal that comes into this place to dilute the intellectual property rights of Australian artists contained in our Copyright Act and other laws, I will vote against it. I will argue against it. I'll vote against it. I'll advocate against it in this place and outside of this place. So if the government is thinking of doing this, think again. My party, the Liberal Party, is founded partly on a respect for private property rights. Any proposal to dilute the intellectual property rights of our creative artists is anathema to the principles and values of the Liberal Party, and I will vote against it and fight against it every single day I am in the Senate. With that, I seek leave to continue my remarks later.

Leave granted.

Sarah Hanson-Young

Sarah Hanson-Young SA, Australian Greens

4:06 pm

I take note of the report, as per Senator Scarr's comments just now. I want to congratulate Senator Scarr for the comments he's made in the chamber just now. This is the type of backbone that we actually need on this issue. And it doesn't matter whether you're a frontbencher or a backbencher or whether you're in the Labor Party or the Liberal Party or on the crossbench; you should be standing up for Australia. And you stand up for Australia by protecting and being proud of laws that have protected people's work for generations.

Australia's copyright laws have been working to protect artists, to protect authors, to protect journalists, to protect academics and to protect Australian creative workers for decades—in fact, over 100 years. And what we know is that there is a proposal on the table cooked together by big AI, who want to come to Australia and convince this parliament to put in place a loophole in copyright law so that they can set up shop here and turn Australia into the Cayman Islands of AI, letting AI companies from all over the world dodge the basic principles of property rights, just as Senator Scarr has outlined.

I commend the speech to the chamber we've heard just now, and I hope that both sides—the Labor Party and the Liberal Party—are taking note. This is an issue that cuts across political divides. This is about the rights of Australians, whatever your job and whatever your creative output, to be paid for the work you do and to have control over what happens to it. No-one should be sold out as a lamb to the AI slaughter in the desperation to let these big, trillion-dollar companies set up shop here. These companies—there are only a handful of them; we're talking four or five—are the biggest companies in the world. They're going around gloating about how they're worth a trillion dollars. Well, if you're worth a trillion dollars, pay some money for the work that you want to take from other people. It's not as if they can't afford it. You've got to wonder how they made all that money in the first place. Have they already not been paying for things? If that is the case, they should also pay reparations. They should sign deals with the artists whose work they would like to use. They should pay the workers who create the work, and they should ask for permission first.

The Albanese government needs to have a backbone. Take a note out of Senator Scarr's words here. This is about standing up for Australian culture, for our values and for the protection of our workers. These are our stories. These are our memories. This is what makes being human worth it. Don't just hand it over to a computer or some tech bro who wants to make another trillion bucks off the back of hardworking artists and creators.

Richard Colbeck

Richard Colbeck Tasmania, Liberal Party

4:10 pm

Acting Deputy President Scarr, I would like to associate myself with, particularly, the comments that you made in your presentation just a few moments ago. This, for me, is also a very important issue. I come from a family where my dad has been involved in the creative arts since I can remember. He held his first exhibition at the age of 92, just a couple of years ago. It's very important to us as a family. My sister has made her living out of the arts for a long time, and I enjoy photography, which is one of those creative endeavours that have been subject to some controversy in recent times, with big organisations such as Adobe utilising the data that they store on our behalf in their cloud to train their AI programs, which we benefit from at the end of the day through having better tools to edit our photographs. But the principle that you explained in your presentation—

No, not landscapes, but we'll deal with that more quietly. I can find you a decent one if you like. Acting Deputy President Scarr, the principles that you explained were that, if big AI wants to come to this country and use the work of our creative artists, from whatever area it might be—whether it's from music, prose literature, poetry, photography or whatever it might be—to train their AI, they can seek permission from the artist, from the creator, and they can pay to do that. I don't think there would be an objection if that were the case. They say it's too hard and too complicated and that people are too dispersed. Interestingly, it sounds very similar to the arguments that we heard back in the early days of music streaming, when it was going to be such a significant problem, yet the music streaming companies seem to find a way, and that now is a source of opportunity for many of our creative artists to publish their work online and get paid for it. So I think those are the principles that need to be applied to this.

There's a lot of discussion about the community dividend out of AI coming to this country, and there are enormous opportunities for this country from the advent and the operation of AI. But principally, at the outset, I think making sure that those whose work is being used to train AI have proper agreements with the AI companies and are properly compensated is a very strong place for us to start with respect to our principles as to how we approach this. This is going to make a change to the way that we live and operate. There's no question about that. It already has started to do that. But making sure it's founded on strong principles is where we should start. So we should be getting that done as quickly as possible but not selling this country out in terms of other countries or the systems that we have. You made the point about our copyright laws in this country. They've been very strong. They've served us exceptionally well for a long period of time, and they shouldn't be compromised at this point in time either. I seek leave to continue my remarks later.

Leave granted; debate adjourned.