This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Questions without Notice

Migration


Tyron Whitten

Tyron Whitten WA, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party

2:52 pm

My question is to the Minister representing the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, Minister Watt. According to OECD data, Australia resettles around 10 times as many refugees per person as the OECD average. That means Australians are funding a resettlement program far larger per person than most developed countries. Can the minister explain to struggling Australians why they are not the priority and why they should pay for a larger refugee intake?

Murray Watt

Murray Watt Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Environment and Water

2:53 pm

I did notice the latest part of One Nation's migration policy released this week. I, for one, recognise that, over many decades, refugees who've moved to Australia have made a very positive contribution to our community, whether we're talking about Greek and Italian migrants who came here as refugees after World War II, Vietnamese Australians who moved here as refugees not that long ago and, of course, other countries who've provided refugees to our country in more recent times.

I'm also aware that there are a number of regional communities around Australia—places like Wagga Wagga, Shepparton or Toowoomba—whose economies would really be struggling without the contribution of refugee Australians. But, of course, we know that One Nation's migration policy doesn't take note of any of that, and we know that One Nation's migration policy would be an absolute hammer blow to the economy of Australia, particularly some of those regional communities which have received refugee communities.

Senator Whitten, I don't know whether you've ever been into an abattoir or an aged-care facility in some of those regional communities, but very often the workers that you'll meet in those communities and in those facilities are of a refugee background. It might be good, cheap politics for your party to come out with policies like that, but you're actually saying to those regional communities that their abattoirs will close, their aged-care facilities will close and a range of other businesses will close as well because they won't have those workers. I'd encourage you, as you're thinking about your migration policies, to think about what is going to work for the Australian economy, including in our regions.

Tim Ayres

Tim Ayres NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Industry and Innovation

Not fit, not fit!

Murray Watt

Murray Watt Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Environment and Water

As Senator Ayres says, time after time we see from One Nation that they are a risk to our economy and they're simply not ready to govern.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Whitten, first supplementary?

Tyron Whitten

Tyron Whitten WA, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party

2:55 pm

Minister, veterans who serve this country are sleeping rough while the government funds 20,000 refugee places a year. Treasury modelling puts the average net lifetime cost of each humanitarian entrant at around $523,000 to taxpayers. What does Labor say to veterans and citizens who are doing it tough, and will they be prioritised over humanitarian refugees for benefits and support?

Murray Watt

Murray Watt Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Environment and Water

I did notice, again, that when One Nation released its latest migration policy this week they had refused to have it costed by the Parliamentary Budget Office—and it's not the first time they've done that. I'd be very wary of taking One Nation's estimates—or should we say 'guesstimates'—about the cost of any policies that they put forward.

Senator Whitten, I've made this point to you before but I'll make it again: veterans who've served our country absolutely need a roof over their head. What's helping to do that is the funding from this government to social and affordable housing for veterans which your party voted against. You consistently come in here and demand that we take action to support members of the community who deserve that support, and then you absolutely mislead those people by coming in here and voting differently. You should think about how you vote, not just about what you say.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Whitten, second supplementary?

Tyron Whitten

Tyron Whitten WA, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party

2:56 pm

Minister, Australians are doing it tough. Rent, mortgage payments, power bills, fuel and groceries are taking more out of every pay packet, and too many households are going without. Labor's national platform commits to lifting the intake of refugees to 27,000 places. Why should Australian taxpayers be funding more places when they can't afford to pay their bills at home?

Murray Watt

Murray Watt Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Environment and Water

2:57 pm

Senator Whitten, one thing I agree with you on is that there are many Australians doing it tough right now. But where I think we disagree is on what we should do about that. I reckon, and Labor reckons, that we should be investing in social and affordable housing for those who need it; you voted against it. I think we should be providing cheaper medicines to people who need them; you voted against it. I think we should be providing cheaper child care to those who need that support; you voted against it. I think we should be providing more bulk-billing for GP appointments; you opposed that as well.

This is the problem that One Nation has: you say you want people who are doing it tough to get a better lot in life, yet you use your opportunity, when you come to parliament, to vote against that. You consistently mislead the people in our community who need support the most. You repeatedly show that you're simply not ready to govern. I see that, today, One Nation's general manager in Victoria has been put on leave—just like you lost your national campaign director. You can't run a party, let alone a country. (Time expired)