This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Questions without Notice
Mid-Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
2:29 pm
My question is to the Minister representing the Treasurer, Senator Gallagher. Minister, the Albanese government has indicated that this midyear budget update will have substantial budget cuts. When so many Australians are doing it tough and the government has already been cutting the NDIS and chasing budget cuts against pensioners, will your government rule out an austerity budget?
Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service
2:30 pm
I thank Senator Shoebridge for the question. I think the Treasurer and I have been clear—and, indeed, the Prime Minister as well—in the last few weeks that we are taking an approach similar to the approach that we've taken in previous budgets and budget updates in relation to finding savings and reprioritisations. We've found $180 billion worth of reprioritisations and savings, and they've been targeted savings—areas where we think reforms are sensible and where we can find savings within agencies' budgets and reprioritise, in some instances, into other areas of increasing need, and we will continue to do that. We do take our job seriously and our responsibility seriously to make sure that the decisions we take are not adding to pressure in the economy but, at the same time, that we are supporting households where we can and dealing with some of the increasing pressures that the budget faces.
These are genuine challenges not just here in Australia but around the world: how do we meet the increasing needs around health, around aged care, around national security, around disaster resilience? This is one of the fastest-growing areas of pressure on the budget. Those opposite won't care about it, because they don't think climate change is real, but there was a 280 per cent increase last year in spending on disaster recovery. If that doesn't tell you there's something going on, I don't know what will—a 280 per cent increase. The decisions we take are about making sensible savings where we can, reprioritising into other areas and meeting some of these increasing pressures that are facing the budget.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
2:32 pm
Well, Minister, you won't rule out an austerity budget, but you could scrap private-jet fuel discounts to billionaires that will cost the budget $640 million next year alone. You could stop fossil fuel subsidies to corporations, costing the budget $16.3 billion a year. You could end AUKUS and have an extra $375 billion in the pocket. Why is it, when you look at cuts, you never look at cutting the money that goes to the one per cent?
Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service
Well, it must be nice and easy to live in the Greens' utopia world, where you don't actually have to deal with any of the challenges that are being faced by the country. We accept that's your position, Senator Shoebridge, and you don't have to actually engage in some of these challenges; you just ignore them and just press on and don't care about them. But we in government have to take some of these issues, particularly those about national security and defence, seriously and respond.
I would also say, Senator Shoebridge, that this government has done more tax reform than any other government over the past few decades, and you can hear every day in question time that we're criticised for it. I would say to you, Senator Shoebridge, before we get to your list of other areas you would like to see tax reform in: how about we do the tax reform that's before us now, in trusts, which is actually trying to deal with an area and make it fairer for working people? We're in your hands.
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
2:33 pm
People are doing it tough and desperately need support, and one thing they could get is a clear statement from this government about wages. The Greens clearly say that wages should be growing faster than inflation. We're clear about it. Can your government do the same? Will you come up and say that, right now, wages need to be growing faster than inflation? Will you say that?
Tim Ayres NSW, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Industry and Innovation
When are you going to deal with—
Sue Lines President
Order! Senator Ayres, I'm going to remind you that, when a senator is on their feet, asking a question, there needs to be silence. Minister Gallagher.
Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service
2:34 pm
I think everyone would want to see real wages growth, but, whilst inflation is higher than we would like, and it's remaining here for longer than we would like, that is challenging. I thought the wages data yesterday, of 3½ per cent, again, was stronger than many in the market expected. But, again, it shows the effort that we have put into not only changing legislation to make sure that it's working for working people, but also the investment by this government. We are criticised widely, across the media and across the opposition, for investing in wages in aged care and for the early childhood educators that you left undervalued and underpaid for a decade. We're dealing with it. It's one of the biggest areas of investment, of spending, that you think is wasteful. And we have actually made the investment.
Sue Lines President
Minister, please resume your seat. Senator Shoebridge?
David Shoebridge NSW, Australian Greens
On relevance, President: my question was, 'Does the government support wages growing faster than inflation?' and I'm yet to hear an answer.
Sue Lines President
Thank you, Senator Shoebridge. I am hearing the minister being relevant to your question, and I'll continue to listen.
Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service
I answered that in the first 10 seconds. Obviously, Senator Shoebridge wasn't listening.
Richard Dowling Tasmania, Australian Labor Party
2:35 pm
While she is on a roll, my question is to the Minister for Finance, Senator Gallagher. Since coming to government, the Albanese Labor government has made responsible decisions to find $180 billion in savings and reprioritisations so we can provide cost-of-living support to Australians and keep funding services Australians rely on. How have those decisions ensured that we are continuing to fund essential services and invest more into services that Australians rely upon, like Medicare?
Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service
2:36 pm
I thank Senator Dowling for that question, and it is an important one as we head into the final weeks of finalising decisions in the mid-year economic and fiscal update. Senator Dowling is right that the government has found substantial savings—more savings than any other government in recent times; more savings and more reprioritisations across government. We have looked widely across government in relation to areas where we think money could be refocused and spent in other areas or in areas where we have reduced spending. We've done that across the Public Service. We've done it in programs like the NDIS—an extremely valuable program, but one which was growing too fast. We've found savings across grant programs. We've found savings in social security. We have looked across the board to find sensible savings where we can, and that has allowed us to make those investments in those key services that Senator Dowling speaks of as well.
Medicare was, and bulk-billing rates were, falling off a cliff when we came to government. We have addressed that with significant investment, and now millions of Australians are able to access bulk-billing doctors, whether it be through the urgent care clinics or through their own private GPs. We've addressed it in relation to medicines, to make sure people can afford the medicines that they need to keep healthy, and we will continue that work.
These are important investments, like investments into aged care. I know people would like to pretend that government doesn't ever need to make a spending decision, but we do. We need to make these decisions to make sure—and they are services that the Australian people value. That is why we will continue on this approach of finding room in the budget, repairing it over time, paying down debt, lowering the deficits and making sure Australians have the services they rely upon.
Richard Dowling Tasmania, Australian Labor Party
2:38 pm
Minister, as you've outlined, the Albanese Labor government has announced several sensible savings measures that would help to reduce spending or make room to fund other important services like supporting our growing aged-care system. Why is it important that these savings are supported by the parliament?
Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service
I thank Senator Dowling for that supplementary. It is important—particularly as to those opposite that are calling for savings—that, when these are brought to this chamber, they are supported. I don't think it's fair to come in and demand that government reduce spending across the board, and then, whenever we bring an idea to the parliament, those opposite criticise it and say no. There is currently in the order of $10 billion worth of savings in this chamber, across various pieces of legislation, and I think the opposition are saying no to all of it.
Now, these are sensible savings. They're targeted savings. It's about making sure that every dollar that's available across the Commonwealth budget is going to areas of priority focus, whether it be aged care, Medicare or repairing the budget over time, and I would say this chamber should engage on that and should pass some of those savings, particularly when those opposite are calling for them.
Richard Dowling Tasmania, Australian Labor Party
2:39 pm
At a time when the budget is facing growing pressures across a range of areas, including health, aged care, disability support and defence spending, how will savings across the budget help to meet these growing pressures?
Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service
2:40 pm
I thank Senator Dowling for that question. It will be with the work we've done already on finding $180 billion worth of savings. But, again, being able to look at ways to invest and strengthen the services that people rely on, whether it be through Medicare—through bulk-billing or through our urgent care clinics—through our cheaper child care, through the investment in more homes that those opposite hate us doing, through extending paid parental leave to six months or through paying fair wages to aged-care workers, early childhood educators, disability workers and community care workers, is how we provide a budget that supports households, particularly at times like these, when there are cost-of-living pressures. We are making sure the services are there without letting people down but also while repairing the budget over time to make sure that it is able to deal with some of the pressures on the Commonwealth budget that are continuing to increase, and we will continue that work through the mid-year economic and fiscal update.