This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Questions without Notice

Taxation


Dean Smith

Dean Smith WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister to the Shadow Treasurer

2:12 pm

My question is also to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong. Yesterday Senator Hume asked whether hardworking family business owners—plumbers, bricklayers and builders—would need to earn $230,000 a year just to avoid paying more tax under Labor's proposed 30 per cent minimum trust tax. Minister, you refused to answer Senator Hume. Instead, you dismissed concerns about the 350,000 Australian small businesses operating through discretionary trusts by arguing that they represent just 10 per cent of small businesses. Minister, since when did 350,000 hardworking Australian small businesses become too insignificant for the Prime Minister to care about?

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

2:13 pm

I would make the point that this package and the various tax packages the government has previously brought forward, and the budget announced, are tax reforms that are all about delivering tax cuts for workers and a fair go for first home buyers and are about better aligning income from work with income earned from investments.

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Opposition Senators:

Opposition senators interjecting—

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

We have delivered—and I know those opposite don't like to be reminded—tax cuts for all taxpayers. It is Labor that has delivered tax cuts for all taxpayers. The first marginal rate was 19c on the dollar when we came to office. It will be 14c next year. We are delivering the Working Australians Tax Offset of $2,250 and a $1,000 instant tax deduction for all workers.

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Opposition Senators:

Opposition senators interjecting—

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

Listen to this. All workers on an average income will be up to $2,800 better off. That is what we are doing to try and ensure we assist and we contribute to employees who are navigating a challenging environment when it comes to the cost of living. So what I would say to you, Senator, is that it is true—

Michaelia Cash

Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate

When these business close, Australians will have no jobs.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

that we are seeking to close the tax loophole which is discretionary trusts. It is true that we have made changes to capital gains tax so that taxpayers—

Michaelia Cash

Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate

Farmers, builders—

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Order! I have called order almost repeatedly. The running commentary from you, Senator Cash, from you, Senator Colbeck, and from you, Senator McDonald, needs to stop. It's rude and disrespectful. Minister, please continue.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

Senator, I said yesterday I would make the point that, in fact, we are seeing more businesses open under this government, and we value the contribution of small business. We do, which is why we have put in place tax measures, including the instant asset write-off, which are beneficial for small businesses. (Time expired)

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Dean Smith, first supplementary.

Dean Smith

Dean Smith WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister to the Shadow Treasurer

2:16 pm

Minister, yesterday, you told the Senate that family businesses could avoid Labor's latest tax, provided they do not change the allocation of distributions from year to year. Who gave Anthony Albanese the right to dictate to 350,000 Australian family businesses how they run their business, distribute their hard-earned money and manage their family finances simply to avoid paying yet another tax grab under Labor?

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Thank you, Senator Smith. Before I call the minister, I remind you that those in the other place need to be referred to by their correct titles. I do remind the Senate that that question was asked in complete silence and I expect the same respect to be given to the minister when the minister responds. Minister Wong.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

2:17 pm

First, what I would say is that it is a matter for individuals and for businesses to make their own decisions about their tax affairs, as they currently do. Secondly, what we are saying is that it is reasonable for us to better align the treatment of income earned from assets with income earned from labour. It is a fair and equitable position.

Jacinta Nampijinpa Price

Jacinta Nampijinpa Price NT, Country Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Skills and Training

No, it isn't; they're being forced.

Jane Hume

Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations

They're workers.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Minister Wong, please resume your seat.

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Opposition Senators:

Opposition senators interjecting—

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Order! I thought I might have a go before I called the minister to remind you of what your obligations are at question time, and your first obligation is to listen in respectful silence. And you did for the first couple of seconds, but then you started. The interjections have to stop. Minister Wong, please continue.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

It is reasonable for us to better align the treatment of income earned from work and income earned from assets. That is a reasonable position to take. I appreciate you don't agree with it. You want the current privileges in the tax system to remain. We think that it is unfair that five per cent of Australians who receive tax distribution should have a better position than Australians who receive that income from work. That is a philosophical difference and it is a— (Time expired)

Dean Smith

Dean Smith WA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister to the Shadow Treasurer

2:18 pm

() (): Minister, yesterday, you said family businesses could simply restructure into companies or fixed trusts to avoid Labor's latest tax hike. With 350,000 Australian small businesses operating through discretionary trusts, inflation at 4.3 per cent, interest rates at an 18-year high and record business insolvencies, why should hardworking businesses, bricklayers and builders face tens of thousands of dollars in restructuring costs just to avoid paying more tax under Labor? (Time expired)

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

2:19 pm

There are some 800,000 discretionary trusts in this country. About half of them are not affected in any year by these changes. I again say about 95 per cent of individual tax filers do not receive a discretionary trust distribution, and 90 per cent of small businesses are not affected in any given year. I do think it's interesting that those opposite are more interested in defending the arrangements on trusts, in defending five per cent of taxpayers, but went to the last election under Senator Hume with higher taxes for working Australians. She is the senator for higher taxes. She went to the last election with the Liberal Party actually suggesting that working people, wage earners, should pay higher taxes. It says everything you want to know about the modern Liberal Party.