This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Barbara Pocock SA, Australian Greens
12:35 pm
Today I want to speak about this Labor government's disgraceful failure to reform and regulate the deeply broken auditing and consulting sectors while those who uncovered and pursued their wrongdoing have paid the price. This parliament has now spent almost four years holding the marauding cowboys in PwC, KPMG, Deloitte and EY to account. We have uncovered scandal after scandal. PwC and Mr Peter Collins monetised confidential government information to help some of the world's biggest multinationals avoid tax, earning at least $2½ million in revenue for PwC as a result. KPMG has consistently overcharged and underdelivered leaked confidential client information in the pursuit of profit. It's lied to the parliament. It's cheated on internal exams. It's mistreated whistleblowers. And it's indulged in a huge cover-up.
These scandals informed a laundry list of recommendations of action agreed to by Labor, the Liberals and the Greens, with all the committee members in agreement. We all agreed that PwC should not have been allowed to tender for government work until all investigations into their appalling behaviour had concluded. Yet this government let them back in. We all agreed that partnership caps should be reduced, that we need a serious penalty regime and that large firms should not be allowed to provide both audit and non-audit consulting services to the same client. They use one to inform the chasing of business with the other. It's totally immoral. We all agreed that whistleblower protections need to be extended to staff in all these big partnerships, and we need a whistleblower protection authority.
It's now been two years since these two tripartisan reports made 52 clear recommendations for reform. How long do we have to wait? What's happened since then? Barely any of those recommendations have been implemented, all while we've been uncovering more rot inside the big four. The ongoing KPMG scandal has uncovered damning evidence of their toxic culture of retaliation, fear, retribution and the pursuit of revenue and profit at any cost, ethics falling at the first hurdle. They've made an incredible commitment to cover-ups over and over again. KPMG in Australia made $2.257 billion last year. A significant portion of that is from government contracts—from taxpayers' money—for a firm that bullies whistleblowers, steals confidential client information and lies to parliament. It should not be allowed to do government work.
We need to ban unethical contractors like KPMG from government work, and all their current contracts should be reviewed. That's why the Greens have a bill before this parliament, which Labor and the Liberals have refused to support, that would ban unethical contractors. The government's own independent reviewer into KPMG recommended that Finance should strengthen their procurement framework, including to restrict or prohibit suppliers from bidding for Commonwealth government contracts where appropriate. Finance couldn't even agree to this recommendation in full, saying the government would respond in due course. In due course! How long do we have to wait? What will it take for this government to act? When KPMG's large private-sector clients are all dumping them as auditor—Macquarie, ANZ, Lendlease, Crown Resorts and Australian Ethical—why has the government still left the door open to them coming back in February as contractors to the government? Government should be leading the pack on decent behaviour here, not falling behind the standards out there where private industry are blowing the whistle and refusing to do business with this mob, given their recent behaviour. The big 4 are the epitome of corporate greed and unethical practice at the most senior level. There are many good people working in these firms; their leadership and their business model has led them into appalling behaviour again and again. They have proven that they do it over and over. So far, this Labor government has refused to regulate, restructure or punish the big four despite the mountain of evidence we have.
It's clear what must be done. Labor, Liberal and Greens parliamentarians in this place have already sorted it out. In estimates, I asked Minister Gallagher if we can expect to see legislation that will finally regulate this sector that has gone so rogue. She couldn't say. This is not good enough. Labor is doing yet another round of consultation, but they know what needs to change. The question is whether they will stand up to their corporate mates and their political donors and finally take on the big end of town. The recommendations for multiple consulting inquiries have sat at the feet of this government, now, for years. We must subject these massive partnerships to the same rules of tax—they don't pay corporate tax, and they don't pay payroll tax for payments to their partners! It's completely inequitable and doesn't pass any kind pub test.
They don't have the same kind of transparency and whistleblowing requirements that face other large entities throughout our corporations law. They separate the functions of consultancy from audit. We must do that, and we have to regulate them properly. The KPMG whistleblower has said that speaking out about the appalling behaviour at KPMG has had devastating consequences for them, and they've said they wouldn't do it again, not because the matters were not worth raising but because of what blowing the whistle at a firm like KPMG and the inadequacy of legal protections actually meant for them. We would not have learned all of the things that we have about KPMG if it weren't for the brave, determined whistleblower who raised these issues at more than seven levels of the firm, both inside and beyond, internationally, before bringing them, as a last resort, to this parliament over and over again.
The PwC scandal would not have surfaced if it weren't for the diligent and determined work of those in the TPB, the Tax Practitioners Board, and, in particular, the work of Mr Michael O'Neill and his team who were tenacious in tracking down and bringing into the public view a range of scandals and concealment—work they did against pressure from other parts of government regulation who did not want to see the kinds of consequences that we eventually did for PwC. They wanted to run a bad-apple theory, hang out Mr Peter Collins to dry and leave the firm alone. The work of the TPB pulled that charade into public view and made sure that PwC picked up the full consequences, across the firm, of its appalling behaviour.
The TPB was crucial in acting against former PwC partner Peter Collins and the whole of the firm, yet Mr O'Neill was subject to at least six attempts to sideline or sack him as CEO while he led the investigation into PWC, including claims that he was acting illegally and unsubstantiated claims of bullying. We've all seen this before in workplaces. When you're doing your job well and causing discomfort to those above you, you can face all kinds of pressure. Believe me, Mr O'Neill faced the lot. He was eventually sidelined and moved into another regulator. I requested to hear directly from Mr O'Neill about these attempts through a question on notice, and he was never allowed to respond in his own voice despite my specific request in that question on notice that he be allowed to make his account of these events public. He has never been heard, against the specific request that he do so.
I believe the Senate has been deliberately mislead by a critical public servant who is the head of a regulator. Regulators, in some cases, are senior in these organisations and come from long careers inside the very consulting organisations that they are now regulating. It is a revolving door that is corrupt and wrong. It doesn't pass any kind of test on perceived or actual conflicts of interest. I tried to table a complaint document from Mr O'Neill in estimates, but the committee refused to table it—so far. We're still working on it. We're still talking about it. The committee is in the process of reviewing it, but I want to put on the record that this is not a trivial matter, nor is it an internal employment matter, as these issues so often are characterised as.
Everyone in this parliament should be paying attention to this issue, and I'm here to make sure his complaint, because of its significance for regulation of and decent practice in our system by public servants and whistleblowers whose complaints should be followed through and pursued, is taken seriously and investigated. Bad behaviour thrives in darkness, so we need to protect our whistleblowers, we need to make sure our regulators are robust in their activities, and we need to rat out inappropriate behaviour to shut down regulation where it occurs. That is our responsibility as a parliament. (Time expired.)