This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Bills

Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026; Second Reading


Anne Ruston

Anne Ruston SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Health and Aged Care

6:35 pm

I rise to speak on the Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026. Let me say from the outset the coalition will not be opposing this bill; it's sensible, and it's a technical change. But it comes before this chamber at a time when the Albanese Labor government is making it harder for the very people this registry exists to protect to get a new hip or a new knee at all.

The National Joint Replacement Registry has been tracking joint replacement surgery in this country for more than 25 years. It's run by the Australian Orthopaedic Association, and it captures data on nearly every knee, hip, shoulder, elbow, wrist and spine procedure, in public and private hospitals alike. It has now recorded more than one million hip replacements. That data tells surgeons which devices perform well and which devices don't. When someone has a new hip or a new knee put in, they want to know that it will last. This registry means their surgeon can now see how every device is performing. When a device starts to fail, it is often this registry that raises the alarm first.

Australia's registry was one of the first in the world to identify problems with a metal-on-metal hip that was later recalled around the globe. That is the value of good data; it protects patients. The registry is funded through a levy on companies that supply these devices. At the moment, that levy is capped at $5,000 per device each financial year. The bill removes that cap so the levy is shared according to how many devices each company actually supplies. It makes it fairer. It has the support of the Australian Orthopaedic Association, Private Healthcare Australia and the Medical Technology Association of Australia. It comes at no cost to the Commonwealth.

The committee has now reported, and the coalition has considered its findings. But I cannot speak about a registry that measures joint replacements without asking whether Australians can get one done at all. Joint replacements are classed as 'elective surgery', but ask anyone waiting for a new hip or a new knee whether it feels 'optional'. A joint replacement might be called 'elective', but, for the person who is waiting for it, it is nothing but optional. It is the difference between walking to the shops and not, between minding the grandkids and staying at home in pain, and between living independently and needing help.

Here is who has these operations: somewhere between 60 and 70 per cent of hip and knee replacements are performed on Australians over the age of 65, and around 70 per cent of them are done in private hospitals. Think about that. The Australians most likely to need a new hip or a new knee are older Australians, and most of them get them done under private health insurance. This is exactly why the Albanese Labor government's cut to the private health insurance rebate that they are trying so desperately to get through this place is so damaging. More than 1.3 million Australians would lose part of their rebate, and around 1.2 million of them are pensioners—over 700,000 of those are full pensioners.

The department's own figures show around two million of the people targeted live on less than $37,000 a year. A single person over 70 on gold cover would pay around $400 more every year if the government's legislation gets through. These are not people who've been dodging paying their share. The government's own data shows that 96 per cent of over-75s hold gold or silver cover, compared to 59 per cent of those under 65. Australians who are older are already doing the heavy lifting when it comes to paying for private health insurance, and this government wants to punish them for that.

The minister has told Australians that 44,000 older Australians will drop their cover. Documents released under FOI show his own department expects that to be 78,000 people by 2029-30, and they're not prepared to admit what will happen after that. That's only the people who walk away altogether, and here's why that matters. The department told the Senate inquiry that joint replacements, along with cataract surgery and dialysis, are among the most common services older Australians use that are only guaranteed under gold cover. Catholic Health Australia estimates one in five affected over-65s will change their level of cover. That is around 665,000 downgrades. The government assumed it would be one in 75.

The department has admitted its modelling cannot even identify who holds gold cover anyway, so this government has no idea how many older Australians stand to lose guaranteed cover for a new hip or a new knee, and when they need that operation, they will not stop needing it; they will join the public waiting list. Half of all public patients waiting for a knee replacement wait for more than eight months, and almost one in four waits for more than a year. That's a year in pain, a year with broken sleep and a year of losing strength, fitness and independence. Not one state or territory has supported this cut, because the longer people wait, the harder their recovery becomes, and the more it costs when they end up in the public hospital system.

In Labor states and coalition states alike, the governments that actually run our public hospital systems have warned of longer waits and higher costs. This rebate cut is not a saving; it's a cost-shift from Canberra onto state and territory hospitals and onto patients, the majority of whom are age pensioners. This Senate has already said so. On 14 October, this chamber voted 38 to 23 to discharge the government's rebate cut bill from the Notice Paper. Less than 24 hours later, the minister introduced exactly the same bill in the other place. Not one word changed. He called the Senate's decision an 'absolute travesty'. The real travesty is asking pensioners to pay more for the cover they've held for 30, 40, 50 or 60 or, in some instances, 70 years. That is the real travesty.

On the same day, in the other place, government members voted against the coalition's amendment to this very bill, an amendment that did little more than set out the facts that I have just put down in the Senate. The government has a bit of a habit of announcing things and then doing the work afterwards. In this case, they haven't even done any real work afterwards. They did not brief the opposition or the crossbench on the bill. Their own department has actually acknowledged it didn't even consult the sector on the cut to this rebate, let alone consult the older Australians whom it was going to impact. Until it was forced into doing so, it did not bother to count how many pensioners it would hurt. One official told the Senate inquiry: 'We didn't know there were pensioners.'

This registry does important work, and we are happy to support this bill. It can tell us what we need to know, but it cannot fix up the challenges that are going to be placed on our public health systems and the burden that's going to be put on our pensioners by the continued decision of the government to pursue the over-65s' private health insurance rebates. The problem, of course, is that, whilst this register can tell us how many people will get a new knee replacement or a new hip replacement, it cannot tell us about the people who are stuck on the waiting list. A registry can only record the operations that actually happen.

As I said, the coalition will not oppose this bill. We support the registry and the important work that the Australian Orthopaedic Association does. But we will keep fighting the government and its cut to the private health insurance rebate for older Australians every time the minister brings it back here. These Australians did the right thing. They paid their premiums for decades, and they deserve better than to be pushed onto a public waiting list in their 70s, after they've paid their premiums for most of their lives. I move the second reading amendment circulated in my name:

At the end of the motion, add ", but the Senate:

(a) notes that:

(i) despite joint replacements being considered elective surgery, they are often critical for a patient's overall health and wellbeing as well as their broader productivity,

(ii) approximately 60 to 70 per cent of total hip and knee joint replacements are performed on individuals aged over 65,

(iii) the majority (around 70 per cent) of total knee and hip replacement surgeries occur in the private sector,

(iv) the Government's proposal to cut the private health insurance rebate for over 65s will force many older Australians to downgrade or abandon their private health cover,

(v) individuals who are no longer covered by private insurance for joint replacements will join public waiting lists,

(vi) public elective surgery waiting lists have blown out with some patients waiting months or even years to access joint replacement operations,

(vii) the Government reintroduced its private health insurance rebate cut, unchanged, less than 24 hours after the Senate discharged it from the Notice Paper; and

(b) criticises the Government for cutting the private health insurance rebate for over 3 million older Australians, including over 1.2 million pensioners".

I commend this amendment to the Senate and I urge every senator who stood up for older Australians on 14 October to stand with them again. I urge the government to rethink their position and to stand with older Australians on this amendment and prove that you actually do care about the wellbeing and health of older Australians.

Carol Brown

Carol Brown Tasmania, Australian Labor Party

6:46 pm

I rise to support the Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026. It changes how medical device companies share the cost of running the national joint replacement registry. It does not change what the registry does, and it does not impose a new charge on patients.

For someone living with a painful joint, a replacement can mean being able to walk more comfortably, return to work or get through the ordinary tasks of the day with less difficulty. Those are the things a person wants to be able to talk about with their surgeon. What they may not see is the work that goes on after the operation, to understand how joint replacements are performing and what can be learnt for the next patient.

The Australian Orthopaedic Association established the registry in 1999 and still runs it. It collects information from hospitals around the country on joint replacements and their outcomes. It covers more than hips and knees, and, because it brings records together nationally and over time, it can tell clinicians more than they can learn from the results of a single hospital.

If a particular implant is associated with more repeat operations than others, that is something clinicians need to know. A repeat operation to replace or alter part or all of an earlier joint replacement is known is known as revision surgery. For the person having it, it can mean another period of recovery and another interruption to work or daily life. It also means further treatment and use of hospital resources.

Better evidence about which devices and surgical approaches perform well can help a surgeon and patient weigh their options. It cannot guarantee the outcome of an operation, but it gives them better information to make that decision. That is why our national registry matters in Tasmania. A patient having surgery in our state should benefit from what clinicians and hospitals elsewhere in Australia have learnt. What we learn in Tasmania can help inform care elsewhere, too. I acknowledge the Australian Orthopaedic Association and the hospital staff and clinicians who make it possible to build and maintain that record.

The Commonwealth funds parts of the registry's administration under a grant agreement and recovers those costs through a levy on sponsors of relevant devices. In this context, a sponsor is a business, such as a manufacturer or distributor, responsible for a device on the Prescribed List of Medical Devices and Human Tissue Products. The cost recovery arrangement has been in place since 2009. The question before the Senate is not whether to establish a new funding arrangement; it is whether the current levy shares the cost fairly. At present, the levy for the same joint replacement cannot exceed $5,000 for a sponsor in any financial year. That figure is an annual limit in the levy calculation. It is not a $5,000 charge on an operation or on an individual implant. The calculation takes into account how often the provision of a device is recorded, the device's benefit amount and the funding needed for the registry. When a device reaches the cap, its contribution stops rising, and the costs of running the registry still have to be met. That affects how much of the total falls to other sponsors.

The government's cost recovery review found that this left smaller and medium-sized companies bearing a disproportionate share. The Parliamentary Library Bill's Digest records that 40 sponsors were liable to pay the levy in 202-26. Twenty-two of them had devices subject to the cap, so this is not a provision that has been sitting on the books without much effect; it has made a difference to how the costs are divided. This bill delivers the 2025-26 budget decision to remove the $5,000 cap. That allows the levy to reflect more closely the volume of devices a company supplies, rather than limiting the contribution for a device that is supplied in large numbers and leaving other sponsors to make up the difference.

The explanatory memorandum records that the bill has no financial impact on the Commonwealth, that it is a separate question from how much each company will contribute. Some contributions can change precisely because the bill is changing how the costs are shared.

There are two dates worth distinguishing. The legislation would commence on the 28th day after royal assent, allowing time for the levy rules to be updated. The change would apply to the levy for the financial year beginning 1 July 2027 and for later financial years. Commencement and the first levy year affected are not the same thing.

The consultation on the cost recovery statement raised a wider issue about who benefits from the registry and who should contribute to its costs. It is reasonable to ask those questions, but the Senate can recognise the wider discussion and still make a decision on the Pacific inequity before us. We do not need to leave the cap in place while every question about funding is considered, nor should we ask the bill to do more than it can. It does not add operating lists or change how long someone waits for elective surgery. Those are separate matters. This bill makes the funding arrangements fairer for an existing service that helps clinicians understand how joint replacements are performing and use that knowledge in caring for patients.

Patients should be able to have confidence that the health system continues to learn from their surgery long after they leave hospital. The registry gives clinicians a way to do that. It is reasonable to maintain that work through an existing levy and it is reasonable to ask the companies whose devices are recorded to share the costs more fairly. So as I've said, the Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026 that we're discussing here is a decision to amend the act of 2029 to remove the $5,000 cap per medical device, per financial year. By limiting or eliminating the cap, the amendment ensures the levy, which is important, is allocated in proportion to the actual volume of devices supplied by medical device companies. Again, I say to the Senate that removing the cap will ensure the levy is actual volume of devices supplied, creating a fairer and more equitable distribution of the levy. I commend the bill to the Senate.

David Pocock

David Pocock ACT, Independent

6:54 pm

I rise to speak in support of the Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026. The national joint replacement registry tracks the outcomes of joint replacement surgeries across Australia, helping clinicians to identify poorly performing implants, improve surgical practices and deliver better outcomes for patients. Currently, a $5,000 annual cap on the levy paid by medical device sponsors means smaller and medium-sized suppliers carry a disproportionate share of the cost, effectively subsidising larger companies. This bill removes that cap, ensuring companies contribute more proportionately to the volume of devices they supply. I support this change. I thank the government for it. It's a fairer way to fund a registry that plays an important role in patient safety, clinical accountability and improving health outcomes for Australians. It's an important component of private health insurance legislation.

I will just touch on the broader management of the private health insurance system in a country where we effectively force Australians to take out private health insurance. On 17 February, the health minister approved an average private health insurance premium increase of 4.41 per cent. It took effect on 1 April. That was the largest increase since 2017. The government approved it knowing Australians were already struggling with rising household costs. Bupa's approved increase was even higher, at 4.8 per cent. Bupa had also received approval for a 5.1 per cent average increase in 2025. These are not increases that the government was powerless to stop; private health insurers are legally required to seek ministerial approval for premium increases, and the minister approved them.

Continuing on with Bupa, according to the Australian Private Hospitals Association, Bupa's Australian private health insurance after-tax profit increased by $182.1 million, to $593.9 million, in 2024-25. Not a bad deal—get approval from the minister to jack up your premiums and make more profit. Bupa's own financial results show that its broader Asia-Pacific business, covering Australia, New Zealand and Hong Kong, reported $947 million in underlying profit in calendar year 2025—an increase of 10 per cent. Why are we allowing Bupa to make more profit at a time when Australians are struggling to afford the basics?

Bupa's Australian private health insurance market share was approximately 25.6 per cent at the end of 2025. This is a huge player and this is a company that benefits from government contracts. Bupa's Australian Defence Force health services contract had an estimated value of $3.6 billion over its initial six-year period, as assessed in October 2022. They have a very odd arrangement with Home Affairs where they're contracted to provide health checks for refugees. They've also had contracts worth $263 million with DVA. And let's not forget that they're buying up GP practices and aged-care facilities across the country. The government is giving them billions of dollars in contracts, allowing them to jack up their fees. And what do we see? Bupa's profits go up.

Today the ABC reported that it had obtained an email from one Bupa medical clinic encouraging doctors to increase revenue by billing more chronic condition management plans. The email indicated that appointment books were being scrutinised for potential possible service opportunities. It encouraged doctors to rebook eligible patients for additional services when Medicare rules prevented services being claimed on the same day. Not only is that a disgusting loss of productivity; if that's not illegal, it should be. When the ABC asked Bupa why, it said all it was doing was encouraging preventive care. It seems to me that this is a multinational that is taking us for a ride. We force Australians to take out private health insurance. One of the biggest players in the market picks up billions and billions of dollars in government contracts. When they ask to put up our premiums, the minister says yes, and then they make more profit. All the while, Aussies are getting slugged because of inflation, because of interest rates going up and because of cost-of-living pressures. We've got to do better as a country. We have to do better.

We've seen Bupa in aged care as well. The ABC also revealed recently that Bupa's enhanced dining package costs 42 bucks a day, $15,000 a year, and it sounds like you get a couple of fried eggs, a sandwich and maybe a couple of other extra things, such as the odd dessert. We've got to do better as a country, and I think it is worth noting in a second reading amendment that we've seen these increases to people's private health insurance premiums at a time when people are struggling to afford the basics and are seeing less and less from these companies, who are making more and more profit. We've got to do better as a country. I foreshadow that I will be moving a second reading amendment.

Katy Gallagher

Katy Gallagher ACT, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Public Service

7:00 pm

I thank other senators for their contributions on the Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026 this evening. The national joint replacement registry is administered by the Australian Orthopaedic Association and collects information from all relevant hospitals in Australia to define, improve and maintain the quality of care of individuals receiving joint replacement surgery. The Australian Orthopaedic Association is provided funding to operate the registry through a Commonwealth grant agreement, which is efficiently cost recovered through the imposition of a levy under the Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Act 2009 on joint replacement devices listed on the Prescribed List of Medical Devices and Human Tissue Products.

The purpose of the Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2026 is to remove the $5,000 levy cap per device per financial year. Removing the cap will ensure the levy is allocated in proportion to the actual volume of devices supplied by the medical device companies, creating a fairer and more equitable distribution of the levy. I thank senators for their contributions to debate on this bill.

Raff Ciccone

Raff Ciccone Victoria, Australian Labor Party

The question before the chair at the moment is that the second reading amendment moved by Senator Ruston be agreed to. A division is required. It being after 6.30 pm, we'll have to defer consideration of that amendment until a later hour of the business of the Senate—probably to tomorrow.