This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.

Senate debates Questions without Notice

Migration


Ross Cadell

Ross Cadell NSW, National Party, Shadow Minister for Water

2:37 pm

My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong. Yesterday, the Albanese government was forced into yet another backflip, this time on its controversial backpacker visa changes, following months of criticism from Australia's farming, tourism and hospitality industries. This morning, in a horror movie of an interview on Sunrise with Natalie Barr, Senator Watt was asked whether the government's policy really was 'announce, consult, backflip', to which Minister Watt responded, 'Well, as I say, that's exactly how government works, Nat.' Minister, is it the Prime Minister's position that announcing half-baked policies, ignoring the businesses and people affected by them and then backflipping after months of uncertainty is exactly the way his government should operate?

Murray Watt

Murray Watt Queensland, Australian Labor Party, Minister for the Environment and Water

Tell us about the multiple ministries. Tell us about how to run a government!

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Minister Watt, this is not addressed to you.

Order! Minister Watt and Senator Cash, come to order.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

2:38 pm

First, in terms of orderly government, I can confirm that we have only one Treasurer, one finance minister and one health minister and we run a system of cabinet government. The second point—

Sarah Henderson

Sarah Henderson Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety

The Treasurer's going to be sacked. You're going to have a second treasurer next year.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

President, this has not stopped.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Thank you, Minister—

Order! Senator Henderson, you're not in a debate across the chamber. When I call you to order, I expect you to come to order. If you can't come to order, I invite you to leave the chamber. Minister Wong, please continue.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

Senator, I'd make the point that you criticise and say we don't listen to business. Then you criticise us when we do listen to business. I note that the AHA and others have welcomed the decisions that the minister has taken after consultation with their sectors.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Cadell, first supplementary?

Ross Cadell

Ross Cadell NSW, National Party, Shadow Minister for Water

2:39 pm

Minister, you mentioned the AHA, but the Victorian Farmers Federation President, Ryan Milgate, has slammed the backflip, saying:

This whole thing has been completely unnecessary and a major source of disruption heading into peak season.

Minister, why should hardworking Australian farmers be forced to suffer unnecessary uncertainty simply because this government and Mr Albanese announced these half-baked policies before consulting with the industries that depend upon them?

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

With respect, this is from a party that's chasing One Nation and wants to cut migration more. Let's be clear. This is from a party—and I have respect for you, Senator Cadell. You are a decent guy. But, really, from a party that is chasing One Nation down the antimigration path and never deals with the economic reality of what that would do to Australian farmers, to Australian employers, to our care industries, to Australians in aged-care facilities and to all of those who need support at home, the hypocrisy is remarkable. It is quite remarkable. It is your party that is following One Nation when it comes to migration, and now you are complaining about changes to migration. We consulted with the industry, and we have come to the table with a package that reflects that consultation.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Cadell, second supplementary?

Ross Cadell

Ross Cadell NSW, National Party, Shadow Minister for Water

2:40 pm

Minister, since the most poorly received budget in living memory, the Albanese government has been forced to backflip on its proposed $5,000 veterans cap, reverse its planned reduction in Australia's humanitarian intake, delay the ATO's credit card payment ban and now rewrite its backpacker visa restrictions. How many more decisions must the Albanese government announce, attempt and defend and then backflip on before the Prime Minister finally admits his government has a serious problem listening to hardworking Australians before it announces policy?

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

2:41 pm

We were very clear in the budget, when we announced the largest and most progressive tax reforms that this country has seen for some time—that was a note for Senator Shoebridge, but he's left the chamber—that we would consult on the detail of the changes. That is what we've done, including some that you raised. You might have raised them differently, but you certainly did raise them. That is what responsible government should do.