This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.
Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations
2:00 pm
My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong. Minister, 350,000 small businesses will be hit by your toxic trust tax restructure. They will not only have to get legal and accounting advice, which will cost thousands and thousands of dollars, but also have to rewrite every lease, every licence, every franchise agreement, every employment contract and every supplier contract. How much will that cost Australian small businesses?
Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs
I thank the senator for the question. I'll start by making the point in relation to trusts that only around five per cent of individual tax filers receive a discretionary trust contribution; 95 per cent do not. So let us be very clear that Senator Hume is standing up for the five per cent of taxpayers who get a trust distribution. We are standing up for the 95 per cent of Australians who do not get a trust distribution.
In relation to small business, I have said before here that I believe only 10 per cent of small businesses actually operate through trusts, and we are obviously working through the impact of trust reforms on small business. But again, Senator, I think the question is: why are you standing up for the 10 per cent and not the 90 per cent? Why aren't you standing up for the millions of taxpayers who do not get a trust distribution? It is very clear that those opposite are only interested in the five per cent. They are only interested in safeguarding the tax benefits which accrue to those Australians who do have trusts and distribute wealth through those trusts.
We are engaging in tax reform, which is about making sure we make the system fairer and that we align more fairly the taxation of income from assets and the taxation of income from labour. Given the numbers of Australians who do benefit from a fairer tax system, I would suggest to the opposition that they are on the wrong side of this debate.
Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations
2:02 pm
Minister, you may think that 350,000 small businesses are tax avoiders. Over here on this side of the chamber, we certainly do not. You've told them that, in order to avoid your toxic trust tax, they can enter into excluded election trust regimes. But what happens if their circumstances change, with a son or daughter coming home to work in the family business? Will they be slugged with a 47 per cent tax in that year?
Sue Lines President
Before I call the minister, I'm going to remind senators, particularly those on my left, that Senator Hume was able to give her question in complete and respectful silence, and that is how I expect the answer to be received: in the same way.
Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs
2:03 pm
As I said in my primary answer, the vast majority of small businesses do not operate through a trust. Fewer than 10 per cent are affected in any given year, and the Treasurer has ensured there are a range of options for existing trusts, which include paying a wage to beneficiaries employed in the trust, restructuring into a fixed trust or company with expanded rollover relief, and choosing to be exempt from the minimum tax as long as they do not change the allocation of distributions from year to year.
I would also make this point, Senator Hume: this is a measure which provides a shift in how we tax in this country, a shift that more fairly aligns—
Michaelia Cash WA, Liberal Party, Leader of the Opposition in the Senate
It's called socialism.
Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs
I'll take that interjection. She says it's socialism to tax people more fairly. She says it's socialism to make sure 95 per cent of taxpayers get a fair deal. You are for the five per cent, and we all know that. (Time expired)
Jane Hume Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Employment and Industrial Relations
2:04 pm
Minister, the 350,000 small businesses around Australia that are being hit by your toxic trust tax may not be able to restructure to an excluded election trust. But is it true, as we heard in the inquiry, that the owners of those businesses would need to earn $230,000 per annum in order to not pay higher taxes under your 30 per cent minimum tax?
Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this
Opposition Senators:
Opposition senators interjecting—
Sue Lines President
Once again, before I call the minister, I'm going to remind those on my left that the time for you to make a comment is during taking note of answers, not when the minister is speaking.
Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs
2:05 pm
On small business, as I said yesterday, we understand the extent to which small businesses are a substantially important part of the economy. That is why it is a good thing that we see the number of new small business registrations up. That is why it is a good thing that we are seeing 30 times more businesses opening than closing. It's why it is a good thing that big businesses are required to pay small suppliers faster. And it is a good thing that the Commonwealth, through its procurement practices, is ensuring that we are paying twice as fast as the average. It is a good thing that the budget includes new practical measures worth billions of dollars, including to benefit small business, including making the instant asset write-off permanent—a $20,000 instant asset write-off. This is a tax benefit. This is a benefit to small business. And that is the right thing to do.