This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Statements by Senators

Albanese Government


James McGrath

James McGrath Queensland, Liberal National Party, Shadow Special Minister of State

1:56 pm

Labor's policymaking is all about backflipping. They announce a policy, they defend it, they refuse to engage with stakeholders, they go overseas, they ignore the warnings, they face the backlash, they go overseas again, and then they do the backflip. This is the Albanese Labor government's absurd approach to governing. They lurch from one policy disaster to another while Australians are left to pick up the pieces. Just last week, Labor was forced into an embarrassing backflip on its plans to sell off historic Defence sites after widespread community outrage from veterans and the broader community. Before that, Labor tried to impose a disgusting $5,000 cap on allied health services for veterans. Despite repeated warnings from the coalition, Labor pressed ahead before ungracefully backflipping again. Queensland Labor politicians, like Labor's Ali France in Dickson, even published videos telling veterans that Labor was doing the right thing. Seriously? How about not introducing bad policies in the first place? Then there was Labor's attempt to slash Commonwealth disaster recovery funding, leaving Queensland communities to foot the bill—another spectacular backflip that, again, was defended by Labor's Matt Smith up in Cairns. But who could forget the disastrous plan of Jim Chalmers, the Treasurer, to tax unrealised super gains? That was another thought bubble that was eventually dumped.

But perhaps the biggest backflip of all is Anthony Albanese's broken promise on negative gearing and capital gains tax. Before the election, the Prime Minister explicitly ruled out such changes. Now Labor has done precisely what it promised Australians it would not do. This is not a government that listens to Australians. It is a government that is weak. It is a government that lies. It is led by a weak prime minister who's rarely in the same room as the truth.