This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Adjournment

Howard Government


Malcolm Roberts

Malcolm Roberts Queensland, Pauline Hanson's One Nation Party

9:01 pm

Many Australians say this Albanese Labor government is the worst government Australia has ever endured, but is it? Tonight, I have a quiz, as one of many steps to restore active democracy in our country, which in the last 50 years has declined alarmingly, with huge and needless increases in Australians' cost of living, needless dishonest reductions in standards of living and the gutting of personal and national finances and security. For each quiz question, name the Prime Minister, the PM.

Who was Prime Minister of the government that legislated the Renewable Energy Target, mandating solar and wind power, giving us unaffordable electricity and cutting stability, reliability and security? Which Prime Minister's government stole farmers' property rights and deceitfully bypassed the Constitution to comply with the UN's Kyoto climate and energy protocol? Which Prime Minister's government concocted the National Electricity Market, a bureaucratically controlled electricity racket making electricity unaffordable? Who was the first major party leader to adopt as policy an emissions trading scheme—a carbon dioxide tax? Who was the Prime Minister, the PM, whose government claimed these policies and legislation were based on climate science? Yet, six years after leaving as PM, he admitted in distant London that, on the topic of climate science, he was agnostic. He did not have the science, after his government said it did.

Which PM's government started mass immigration and doubled immigration across its term, and removed house prices from the consumer price index, thus hiding a major damaging impact of mass immigration? Which PM's government rewrote the banking code of conduct to remove banks' obligations to provide a fair level of service and honest conduct? Years later, we needed a royal commission to identify the resulting abuses of borrowers, businesses, investors and citizens. Which PM, after losing the election, was appointed to an advisory role for JP Morgan?

Which PM, on his return to Australia from America, strode into cabinet and, according to his Foreign minister, announced, 'We're off to Iraq,' based on his government's claims about Iraq's weapons of mass destruction, claims the same government later admitted were false? They were lies. Who was that Prime Minister? Whose government blindly followed the American president into what would become Australia's longest war, Afghanistan, exposing our young men and women to needless harm and death? Who was that PM?

Which PM's government implemented the United Nations Agenda 21 across Australia, right across the country, without naming it? Which PM's government legislated the Water Act, specifying compliance with international agreements? Which PM's government legislated the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act, controlling private land use? Which party leader initiated Pauline Hanson's booting from the Liberal Party and then pursued her and teamed with the then Queensland state Labor premier and government to jail her to perpetuate 'uniparty' governance?

Which PM presided over North West Shelf gas contracts selling out and cheaply transferring Australia's wealth to foreign multinationals? Which PM's government signed Australia up to the unaccountable International Criminal Court, which then piled unfounded constraints and burdens onto our country? Which PM's government introduced the National Curriculum with its roots in the unelected United Nations, corrupting education into indoctrination, hurting children and families and driving one of the foundations in Australia for the UN's antihuman ideology?

Which PM's government gave $20 million to the WWF that's working to shut down our beef, coal and fishing and to control private property? Which PM's government introduced middle-class welfare? As famous author Alexis de Tocqueville said, once people get a taste of government largesse, there's no going back. They want more and more. People become dependent on government and surrender to government control. Which PM's finance minister said in recent years that he, the Treasurer and the Assistant Treasurer worked to stop the PM's wasteful spending, seemingly aimed at winning votes and elections to stay in power? According to the book Anglophobia on pages 103 and 104, which PM initiated the Aboriginal Voice concept? Which PM's government strongly supported multiculturalism, while portraying himself as a supporter of Anglo-Celtic heritage? Which PM's government extended the nuclear ban? Which PM's government outsourced and started destroying the Defence department?

Which PM spoke about federalism and states' rights as a cover for his centralist actions? Which PM talked about the Constitution, borders, property rights and other issues, falsely cultivating his image as a conservative patriot and nationalist, while pushing globalist UN policies? Which former PM entered federal parliament in 1974 and the next year became Minister for Business and Consumer Affairs? In 1976 he was in the federal ministry that ratified the UN Lima Declaration, shipping manufacturing overseas. Rising rapidly, he became Treasurer in 1977. Which PM's government used taxpayers' money to bail out a bankruptcy—a company his older brother headed, as non-executive chair? Which PM's government took guns from honest everyday Australians without detailed formal investigation into the Port Arthur mass shooting?

Now for the answers: in every question, the Prime Minister, the PM, was John Howard. Here are excerpts from the late conservative politician and author Viv Forbes's global newsletter of 26 April 2019: 'Then came the Howard era, and again Australians went to sleep, allowing Howard to plant the seeds of many current problems. He had a good careful treasurer who balanced the books. Howard was a Fabian who reassured everyone, scared no one, but went steadily in the wrong direction for too long. He clung to power by appeasing his enemies while betraying his supporters and his principles. He showed that democracy has a fatal flaw—you must buy votes with promises.' Forbes continued: 'The good, the bad and the awful among Australians politicians,' he said, were, 'Good: Menzies/Fadden, Hawke/Keating, Tony Abbott; bad: the LNP lightweights, such as Peacock, Hewson and Don Chipp; very bad and chaotic: Whitlam/Cairns, Gillard/Rudd/Greens; second worst: Turnbull.' And—quoting Viv Forbes—the worst Australian government since World War II was John Howard's. Forbes explains: 'I am sure many will be surprised by my assessment of the Howard era. Howard was a consummate politician—he knew how to win and keep power without frightening the electorate, but had few political scruples or guiding principles. Property rights and freedom to trade were no obstacles to him. He introduced retrospective legislation, levied the fringe benefits tax on the wrong people because he was scared of the unions and invented the GST in a messy form to get Democrat support. He started the carbon wars by implementing the UN Kyoto protocol, and conspired with the states to steal property rights from farmers to achieve the UN Kyoto targets. He concentrated power in Canberra and ratified the UN handcuffs fashioned by Keating in UN Agenda 21. Many great anti-industry "industries" were established or boosted on Howard's watch. They were based on "saving" icons like the Great Barrier Reef, Murray-Darling Basin, forests, wetlands and world heritage.'

Forbes continued: 'Howard also managed to disarm law-abiding Australians and then wastefully destroyed the thousands of confiscated small arms that Australia will surely need one day.' Forbes said: 'I remember seeing pictures of British soldiers during World War II training with broomsticks and then the British Home Guard being supplied with sporting rifles donated by private Americans.'

Forbes said: 'Whitlam would have done far more damage than Howard had he managed to stay in office, but Howard had more time to do more damage, slowly.' That's the end of my quote from Forbes.

Now my confession: I originally perceived John Howard as one of the best Australian prime ministers. I now admit my mistake. After 20 years thorough research, I agree with Viv Forbes. Although the Liberal-National government from 1996 to 2007 had Australia's worst Prime Minister, it contained redeeming MPs, including Peter Costello, who skilfully rode the resources boom; Nick Minchin; John Anderson; Bronwyn Bishop; Kevin Andrews; Russell Broadbent; Ross Cameron; and Brendan Nelson.

Despite these people, Australia's five decades of accelerated demise are due to our deeply troubled democracy slipping from active democracy to passive. People feel hopeless about MPs blindly, corruptly bowing to self-serving personal and party agendas, harming the people and our country. Both parts of the uniparty, Labor and Liberal, are saying they're the parties of government. Yet look around at Australia in decline. That's what you lot, the self-proclaimed so-called parties of government, are inflicting on Australians.

Some of us One Nation MPs have dirty fingernails. We're from the real world and proud of it. In my case, I was working at 15 and later worked as a vineyard labourer, in restaurants, at the coalface in underground mines around Australia and in kitchens. Our country needs government of the people, by real people, for the people—people, not party. Please help us restore our country. Be active. Be involved. Be informed. In Australia's Constitution, the people are No. 1 and supposedly in charge. Please get involved. Restore democracy's only true form, active democracy.

Senate adjourned at 2 1 :11