This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Adjournment

Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026


Leah Blyth

Leah Blyth SA, Liberal Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Defence Infrastructure

8:18 pm

In September this year, I spoke in this place about my opposition to Labor's proposed digital duty of care legislation. It is their failed misinformation and disinformation bill all over again. We all want to keep kids safe online, and we want to keep them as safe as we possibly can, but we've got to consider what freedoms we are trading under the illusion of safety. As I said then, I did not enter this chamber to hand governments more power over what free people may lawfully say, read or see. I entered to defend these hard-fought freedoms. Free speech is not a problem to be managed. It is a freedom that we must value and we must protect.

The digital duty of care bill has the potential to censor and stifle legitimate public debate and lawful speech, and I have significant concerns that this will prevent what we can see and say online about issues like women's sex based rights. Where the minister can decide what constitutes harm and serious harm in relation to online content, I am under no illusion that what this government will censor and ban is any opposition to the ideology they are pushing, like that men can be women. Australian law no longer recognises the biological reality of sex and instead relies on self-identification, which means that legally men who say they are women are offered all the protections of biological women under the law. As confirmed by the Sex Discrimination Commissioner, it means men now have protections for potential pregnancy and breastfeeding, which is downright absurd. Biological males who identify as female and who induce lactation are protected under antidiscrimination legislation designed for breastfeeding women. This is nothing more than state sanctioned perversion. These infants are force-fed a secretion that may or may not be harmful. There is little medical evidence that points to the nutritional value of the secretion or the possible harms.

When Labor's agenda is to have you believe anything, including things that you know are not true, it seems like we are living in George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four. Men can be women, the Prime Minister didn't fall off the stage, you'll save $275 off your electricity bill and you'll only need a Medicare card to see a doctor—all of these things are known not to be true and are not founded in reality or fact. Advocating for the biological reality and simple fact that men cannot be women is possibly to be deemed hostile by the eSafety Commissioner and breach Labor's digital duty of care legislation. Under proposed section 27 of the bill, online services seeking to comply with their obligations must ensure that online risks are being mitigated, which in this case would mean they would simply remove or never post content. Self-censorship to avoid multimillion-dollar penalties will become commonplace. So, if you can no longer advocate for biological reality and scientific fact, does that mean that anything that Labor doesn't support will also be censored? On things like net zero and divisive proposals like the Voice to Parliament, anything at all that is critical of the government has potential to be banned.

These concerns have been raised by the Rule of Law Institute of Australia, and they summarised their evidence in the Environment and Communications Legislation Committee last week. It was also outlined by Mr Merritt from the institute that an online service provider has a greater interest in preserving shareholder funds than in preserving freedom of speech, so it has a very strong incentive to suppress and remove material to avoid the potential of a very large fine. These views do not stand in isolation. At Women's Forum Australia, Rachael Wong and Stephanie Bastiaan have consistently raised concerns with how the eSafety Commissioner is treating speech that raises concerns about gender ideology. But the most striking revelation has come from the Office of the eSafety Commissioner, who have indicated that the wording contained in the digital duty of care bill is too vague.

I want to thank everyone who has reached out to me to voice their concerns about Labor's digital duty of care legislation, as well as those who have reached out and called out the protections for men who are now protected to breastfeed. It makes it impossible to hold governments to account and for Australians to express their freedom under bills like the digital duty of care bill.

Senate adjourned at 20:23