This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Matthew Canavan Queensland, Liberal National Party
2:55 pm
My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong. For most Australians, their home is their biggest financial decision. Property analysts at Cotality say that recent buyers are at the greatest risk of negative equity, and economist Cameron Kushner says that Labor's tax changes have made the housing market weaker. Minister, how many Australians are now watching their life savings disappear because their home is worth less than they paid for it under this government's policies?
Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs
2:56 pm
The first point I'd make is on the assertion of negative equity. I would just point out that the Commonwealth Bank reported in their full year results that negative equity in their portfolio had dropped from 0.8 per cent to 0.5 per cent, and that around the country, according to the Reserve Bank of Australia, fewer than one per cent of mortgage holders are in negative equity.
The point I would make is that—as I have been advised—in 2019, under your government, just over two per cent of borrowers were in negative equity. So, despite the campaign from you, in fact it is now less than half of that. I think this really demonstrates the way in which the coalition is dealing with these issues of housing policy. They are desperate to engage in talking down the market and talking down the economy and have not engaged with the fundamental point, which is that either you are on the side of young Australians who are trying to enter the housing market—either you believe that the great Australian dream should not just be for those who already have houses but should be extended—or you believe that we should continue to have an uneven, unequal playing field as it is between investors buying many homes and a young family buying their first home.
We are very clear that homeownership is part of what this government wants to deliver. We are very clear that this is central to how Australians see and experience their security. We believe more young Australians should be entitled to get into the housing market, and we are backing them. We are backing them through the five per cent deposit scheme. We are backing them by ensuring investment goes into more houses, and we are backing them by a fairer tax system.
Matthew Canavan Queensland, Liberal National Party
2:58 pm
I note the data you quoted there, Minister, only went to the end of June—just weeks after your budget—but more recent data from Cotality says that half of homes bought in Sydney and Melbourne are past 12 months are now worth less than their purchase price and, nationally, one in three recent buyers would sell for less than they pay paid. These are not numbers on a spreadsheet; these are young Australians who are now facing going backwards on their biggest asset. How many of them are now—not back in June but now—trapped in negative equity?
Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs
2:59 pm
What I'd say to you, Senator Canavan, is that when those who were in negative equity were around double the number, in terms of the numbers that Ive just quoted to you from when you were in government, I don’t recall you being the champion on this issue. I don't recall you arguing for a fairer deal for young Australians. The fact is, you are either a government, a party, that believes that you want to extend homeownership to more Australians or a party that says, 'No, we don't think government's got a role in that. We're happy with fewer young Australians getting to the housing market.' Senator Canavan, unfortunately, you and your party and the rest of the right-wing coalition, whether it's the Liberals or One Nation, are all on the same page on this. You don't want more young people into the housing market.
Sue Lines President
Thank you, Minister Wong. We are at the hard marker of 3 pm. We will move on.