This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Senate debates Questions without Notice: Take Note of Answers
Fiscal Policy
James McGrath Queensland, Liberal National Party, Shadow Special Minister of State
3:03 pm
I move:
That the Senate take note of answers to coalition questions 1 and 2.
In particular, we want to relate the Prime Minister's character to the events of the grant to the Marrickville golf club, because what we've seen with the Prime Minister is that he and truth are rarely in the same room. We saw that before the 2022 election, when the Prime Minister promised 97 times to cut power bills by at least $250 yet power bills have gone up. Before the last election, the Prime Minister promised that he would not make any changes to capital gains tax or negative gearing and yet, in the first budget after that election, such changes were made.
Now we get to the issue of the grant to the Marrickville golf club. The Prime Minister, who is the local member, has approved a $6 million grant to a local golf club, a golf club that he said he was unaware that he was an honorary member of. But this is a prime minister who previously said back in 2019 that he declared an interest because of his personal interest and a conflict of interest because of his involvement with the golf club. And now we have a prime minister who somehow manages to conjure $6 million out of thin air to give to his local golf club.
This was not just $6 million. It was $6 million of taxpayers' money, $6 million of a $½ billion gerrymandered fund that was used by the Labor Party during the last election campaign. The Centre for Public Integrity has suggested that this fund was a misuse of public money. Indeed, its chair has said:
I think there's a heavy onus on the government now to justify the process it has used. If they cannot justify that process, then I think the public in Australia would be driven to the conclusion that this is the misuse of public money at a serious level.
It is a misuse of public money, at a national level. It is a serious misuse of public money when the leader of the Labor Party, the Prime Minister of this country, uses this fund as a slush fund to hand out $6 million to his local golf club.
But the Prime Minister's response was to attack the Australian Broadcasting Corporation for, rightfully, putting questions to him, as the fourth estate should—to him and to all politicians. He didn't defend his decision. He didn't justify his decision. He attacked the ABC. So I think the Prime Minister has something to hide here. And we heard from Senator Wong in her answers at question time today that the Prime Minister was not the decision-maker. Hang on: he's the Prime Minister! He's the Prime Minister of this country. Are you seriously trying to tell us that the Prime Minister had nothing to do with $6 million being pulled out of a slush fund and being given to his local golf club?
You're really taking the mickey here. Are you really saying that the minister made this decision off their own bat and had no reference at all from the Prime Minister? The Prime Minister clearly was involved in the decision-making. This slush fund was there to ensure the election of a Labor Party government. The taxpayers of Australia need answers from this government as to how and why these funds were determined and why this golf club alone, of 1,600 golf clubs in the country, was the one special golf club to be chosen to receive $6 million—a hole in one. Talk about that. (Time expired)
Michelle Ananda-Rajah Victoria, Australian Labor Party
3:07 pm
When the Albanese government was elected in 2022 we came in with a very clear promise that we were here to restore faith in politics and in the political establishment. This was after a decade of coalition rule that saw sports rorts, colour-coded spreadsheets, commuter car parks—I remember those well—and of course robodebt bearing down on the Australian people. We saw a weakening of public institutions, we saw attacks on public servants and we saw the coalition perfect the model of taxpayer money being used for their pet projects and slush funds.
Now we have a coalition that is running interference for big tech by opposing the digital duty of care bill as well as running interference for big tobacco. So they are taking this to a whole other level, and they are standing there and pointing the bone at us, claiming that what were genuine and legitimate election commitments that both parties—indeed, the crossbench candidates—have all engaged in are somehow pork-barrelling. I emphatically reject this suggestion.
When I ran for the lower house in the seat of Higgins—which those of you on the other side will remember was held by the Liberal Party for 75 years—I had a whole range of election commitments. Now, I went in not actually believing I would win that seat. That seat had never been held by the Labor Party—ever. And I found that one of the key asks from that community was to fix their swimming pool. The Carnegie Memorial Swimming Pool was leaking, it was overgrown with weeds and it had been drained. But the community had a real affection for this piece of infrastructure. It had been there since the postwar period. I asked them what they needed. They said they needed in the order of $10 million to $15 million to fix the pool. So I made the commitment, after consultation with the party, that I would do that if I won the seat. My point is that these election commitments are made at elections by candidates, and they are contingent on winning the seat. It is not a given that you're going to win the seat, and I certainly didn't expect to win the seat, but, when I did win the seat, I upheld that promise to that community, and that $15 million was given. It underwent rigorous processes. It was managed by the department at arm's length from me and at arm's length from the minister. The money was delivered to the local council, who then chipped in an additional something like $50 million or $60 million, and they built this pool. It was delivered on time. It was actually delivered under budget by that council, who managed it well. The community benefited—not just the community of Higgins but the surrounding neighbours as well.
My point is that election commitments are made in election periods, and they are contingent on actually winning the seat. When the Labor Party wins a swathe of seats, of course more money goes to those seats, which are now Labor seats. When the script is flipped and the Liberal Party or the coalition—if they get their act together—actually win some seats, then more money flows there. The important thing here is that it's not the election commitments per se that we make. It's the fact that, after the candidate is actually successful, the process is well managed by the department at arm's length from the minister. That's exactly what happened with this fund, the Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program. I reject any suggestion that this is pork-barrelling at all. (Time expired)
Paul Scarr Queensland, Liberal Party
3:11 pm
The issue is, when you look at the facts and you look at the statistics, the vast majority of these community projects that are approved through these limited tender processes, where there can only be one tenderer and there can only be one person getting the money, who's been given the benefit of a Labor Party election commitment—203 out of 229 community projects went to Labor held seats. That's 88.64 per cent of these projects in Labor held seats. I recognise Labor Party did well at the last election, but they won 62.6 per cent of the seats. They won 62.6 per cent of the seats, but they get more than 88 per cent of the projects. This isn't about us. It's about the Australian people, and it's about the Australian people, through the length and breadth of this country, getting their fair share of this funding, which is critical.
For every example of a swimming pool in Higgins, I can give you examples all over Australia. This is the point. There should be a competitive process so that communities across the whole of Australia can participate equally in that competitive process, and then, on an objective basis, a decision is made as to where the funding should go. It should be open, it should be transparent, it should be objective, and it should be a matter of integrity. That is what the coalition is calling for. In relation to that issue of integrity, I want to quote from the Centre for Public Integrity Chair, former justice Anthony Whealy, who was an absolute warrior for integrity and transparency in government in Australia:
I think there's a heavy onus on the government now to justify the process it has used.
This isn't Senator Scarr. This is former justice Anthony Whealy:
If they cannot justify that process, then I think the public in Australia would be driven to the conclusion that this is the misuse of public money at a serious level.
That's the phrase the former justice has used—'misuse of public money at a serious level'. That is the concern we're talking about here. It's the fact that 203 out of 229 of these community projects have been delivered to Labor seats.
What about the rest of Australia? Where's their fair share of the funding? We want equality across this country and equality with respect to access to this funding. I'll say this with respect to transparency in the Prime Minister's disclosure. I don't think it was appropriate, with due respect to the Prime Minister, for him to attack the ABC. The ABC were doing their job. They were asking the questions which they should be asking. And good on them for doing that. The Prime Minister should lead the way in terms of disclosure of actual conflicts or perceived conflicts of interest. So I don't think it's right to minimise the fact that there appears to be an issue with respect to the disclosure of the membership of this golf club. I do hope the Leader of the Government in the Senate does come back and provide some further information—and I thank her for taking it on notice—with respect to what steps the Prime Minister has taken to clarify this matter and then to correct the record as soon as possible. That's the example we expect from Australia's Prime Minister.
Carol Brown Tasmania, Australian Labor Party
3:15 pm
I rise as well to take note of the answers given by the minister today. I think it's really important to start with what we're actually talking about, because, so far, in the contributions from those on the other side, it has really been all about politics. The Major and Local Community Infrastructure Program is clear about what it is. It's a one-off closed program established to deliver Labor's publicly announced 2025 election commitments. These commitments were made openly. They were announced. Communities knew what was promised. Australians voted. And this government is delivering what it said it would deliver. But 'closed' does not mean 'unchecked'. Projects must meet program guidelines, demonstrate value for money and meet departmental benchmarks. Local MPs and ministers do not assess projects in their own electorates. That is how accountability works.
Our approach follows the Commonwealth Grants Rules and Principles and the recommendations of the Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audit. There's nothing unusual about a government establishing a program to deliver on its election commitments—nothing unusual at all. In fact, governments of both persuasions have done this for years. The real question is whether the commitments are public, whether there are clear rules, whether value for money is tested and whether independent scrutiny remains in place.
So, having established what this program actually is, I have listened with some amazement to the outrage from those opposite. If the coalition really want to have a debate about the proper administration of grants, I'm very happy to have that debate. Australians remember 'sports rorts', the $100 million competitive sports grants program. Sports Australia assessed the applications against published criteria, but the office of the minister of the time, Senator McKenzie's office, ran its own parallel process, producing multiple versions of colour coded spreadsheets, tracking electorates and political parties, while projects moved on and off the 'approved' list. The Auditor-General found there was no record explaining why some projects were added and others removed. I'm sure Senator Scarr would be very happy to go back and have a look at that report! In the final round, 73 per cent of the grants approved by the minister had not been recommended by Sports Australia.
The sports rorts were not an isolated example in the track record of those opposite when they were in government. My colleague Senator Ananda-Rajah also mentioned these in her contribution. She talked about the coalition's commuter car parks.
I know! They announced hundreds of millions of dollars for car parks overwhelmingly in electorates where they wanted to hold a win. The Auditor-General again found the selection process was not open or transparent and was not merit based. Not one of the original 47 sites selected for funding had been proposed by the department. Seventy-seven per cent were in coalition held electorates. And they come in here, faux outraged, for a political purpose only. (Time expired)
Sarah Henderson Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety
3:19 pm
Yes, we do come in here to raise very serious concerns about the truthfulness and credibility of this Prime Minister. Mr Albanese has serious questions to answer about a $6 million taxpayer funded grant which Labor provided to his local Marrickville golf club. This is not just a simple story about a golf club receiving funding; it is about how the club was selected in the first place. Labor established a $560 million—more than half a billion dollars—invitation-only community infrastructure program to deliver its election commitments. The Centre for Public Integrity has made it very clear that this fund is a misuse of public money or serious pork barrelling. The Chair of the Centre for Public Integrity, former justice Anthony Whealy, said:
I think there's a heavy onus on the government now to justify the process it has used. If they cannot justify that process, then I think the public in Australia would be driven to the conclusion that this is the misuse of public money at a serious level.
Critically, clubs and community organisations could not simply apply for this money. We are talking about more than half a billion dollars. Labor decided who could apply and, out of all the clubs in the entire country, the Marrickville golf club was the only one allowed to apply for funding. Of course, as we know, this club happens to be in the Prime Minister's own electorate. We now know something else. The ABC has reported this morning that Mr Albanese is an honorary member of the club. The club told the ABC he had been on its books as an honorary member for up to 15 years. That membership was not declared on his parliamentary register of interests. The Prime Minister has previously spoken openly about his close connection with the club. He's described going there for decades, walking his dog and using the club—poor old Toto being dragged into it again. But apparently he didn't remember that he was a member and he did not think it was appropriate to declare it. In 2019, when there was a proposal to reduce the golf course from 18 holes to nine, Mr Albanese even publicly declared an interest because of his personal connection to the club.
So Australians are entitled to ask a very simple question: who decided that this particular golf club should be invited to apply for $6 million of taxpayers' money? Labor has still not explained who constructed the list of projects, what process was used to select them or why particular organisations were invited while others were not. An analysis by the Centre for Public Integrity found 73 per cent of the $560 million fund went to seats notionally held by Labor, compared with 23 per cent that went to coalition held seats. This is another serious integrity fail, and the Prime Minister has many important questions to answer.
Question agreed to.