Senate debates Questions without Notice

Attorney-General


Kim Carr

Kim Carr Victoria, Australian Labor Party, Shadow Minister Assisting the Leader for Science

2:00 pm

This is a question to the Attorney-General, Senator Brandis. The Attorney-General, when asked in question time yesterday whether he agreed with Senator Macdonald's statement on the Solicitor-General, advised the Senate that he was not aware of that statement. I ask the Attorney-General: have you, Attorney-General, forgotten that you were asked about the same matter—Senator Macdonald's statement—in a television interview only seven hours earlier?

George Brandis

George Brandis Queensland, Liberal Party, Attorney-General

What I said was that I had not read Senator Macdonald's speech, and I have not.

Stephen Parry

Stephen Parry President

Senator Carr, your supplementary question.

Kim Carr

Kim Carr Victoria, Australian Labor Party, Shadow Minister Assisting the Leader for Science

2:01 pm

I refer the Attorney-General to the actual comments that he made on Sky News at 7.42 am yesterday, where, in response to a question about whether he agreed with Senator Macdonald's assertion, he said, 'I'm not going to associate myself with that remark'. Will the Attorney-General now repeat that position and disassociate himself from Senator Macdonald's remarks?

George Brandis

George Brandis Queensland, Liberal Party, Attorney-General

I do not have a transcript of the interview with Sky News; however, I do have a transcript of my answer to the question yesterday, which has been given to me. What I said yesterday, so you can have the full remark, is this:

I did not see or read Senator Macdonald's speech, and I do not comment, as a matter of practice, on speeches that I have not seen or read.

That is the case.

Stephen Parry

Stephen Parry President

Senator Carr, your final supplementary question.

Kim Carr

Kim Carr Victoria, Australian Labor Party, Shadow Minister Assisting the Leader for Science

2:02 pm

Given that the Attorney-General was clearly familiar with Senator Macdonald's attack on the Solicitor-General, why could he not provide a straight answer to the Senate? Is this yet another example of the Attorney-General being slippery with the facts?

Barry O'Sullivan

Barry O'Sullivan Queensland, National Party

It is the same one, and I am going to persist in making it: the term 'slippery' has connotations—I researched it overnight—and I ask that they withdraw those references.

Stephen Parry

Stephen Parry President

My answer will be the same as to that point of order yesterday. Whilst I am not regarding it as being unparliamentarily, it is borderline.

George Brandis

George Brandis Queensland, Liberal Party, Attorney-General

It was the case yesterday, when I told the Senate I had not seen or read Senator Macdonald's speech, that I had not.

Kim Carr

Kim Carr Victoria, Australian Labor Party, Shadow Minister Assisting the Leader for Science

You were aware of it!

George Brandis

George Brandis Queensland, Liberal Party, Attorney-General

That is not what I was asked, and that is not what I said. It is still the case that I have not seen or read Senator Macdonald's speech.