This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.

The Parliament has not yet published the final text for this day, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may change.

Senate debates Questions without Notice

Artificial Intelligence: Intellectual Property


Sarah Hanson-Young

Sarah Hanson-Young SA, Australian Greens

2:17 pm

My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, Senator Wong. Australia has a copyright regime that's worked for over 100 years, a regime that has protected the rights and supported the employment of creative workers and authors—journalists included—for decades. Why is the Australian government even considering proposals from US AI companies to undermine the very principle of copyright, and isn't it true that an opt-out model undermines the very notion that an artist owns and controls their own work—how it is allowed to be used—and that they're paid fairly for its use?

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

2:18 pm

I thank Senator Hanson-Young for the question. I'd start by saying Australian creatives are world class and we are committed, as a government, to supporting them. But I think in part of your question, Senator, there was a discussion about the history of copyright but not about the current reality, which is that, right now, creators in Australia are for the most part not being paid and have no control. But their works are still being used because, in part, that AI training is not occurring here in Australia. So I think it is wrong to suggest that artificial intelligence, and its deployment, is not already having an effect on Australian rights holders. So the question is not no change. The question has to be: what is the change that best protects and most effectively protects the Australian creatives?

We want to ensure the strongest copyright protection for Australian artists. To do that, that means we need to be active and involved in frontier AI training and development.

I know that the ministers engaged in this—including the Attorney-General and Minister Ayres, and Minister Burke—are engaging very closely with the sector on this, and we understand, absolutely, their concerns. We also are concerned, because this goes not only to their own proprietary interest; it also goes to our identity as a nation, because our creative sector does speak to who we are and expresses our views, our experience and our identity as Australians. So the government will keep engaging constructively. I know the ministers are.

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Hanson-Young, first supplementary?

Sarah Hanson-Young

Sarah Hanson-Young SA, Australian Greens

2:20 pm

In response to the minister's answer to my first question: if work is already being stolen, why are you wanting to legalise that theft?

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

I don't accept the premise of the second part of that question. That is not the approach the government has taken. You know that is not, and I know—

Sarah Hanson-Young

Sarah Hanson-Young SA, Australian Greens

That's what it's going to do.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

It isn't.

Sarah Hanson-Young

Sarah Hanson-Young SA, Australian Greens

That's what's happening.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

Well, Senator, that is not the approach the government is taking. I've outlined to you, and the Attorney-General has outlined to you, what we are seeking to do, and I think it is important that we try to deal with this responsibly, recognising the imperative of the national interest, of ensuring that the copyright protections for our artists and creative sector are effective, in a world where artificial intelligence is—

Sarah Henderson

Sarah Henderson Victoria, Liberal Party, Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety

AGD doesn't even understand copyright law.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

already accessing and utilising—

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

I'm sorry, Minister Wong. Please resume your seat. Senator Henderson, I should not have to call you by name. I called order at least three times. You completely ignored me. When I call 'Order', it applies to you. I expect you to listen in respectful silence. Minister Wong, please continue.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

As the Prime Minister has made clear, artificial intelligence presents significant opportunities, but we must pursue these on Australian terms. (Time expired)

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Senator Hanson-Young, second supplementary?

Sarah Hanson-Young

Sarah Hanson-Young SA, Australian Greens

2:22 pm

The only reason, Minister, we are having this debate is because big AI wants Australia to create a loophole to legalise this theft. As big AI tries to steal from Australian artists, replace Australian workers and take our water and energy, does the Prime Minister stand with Jimmy Barnes and the working class man, or big tech?

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

The Prime Minister and this government stand for Australia, always, and—

Sue Lines

Sue Lines President

Order! Minister Wong.

Penny Wong

Penny Wong SA, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Foreign Affairs

First, artificial intelligence presents enormous opportunities and great risks—and there will be differences of views about how they are to be navigated. But it is, I think, not open to any government—and, frankly, not to any serious political party—to pretend you can just avert your eyes and that things will never change. They are changing. So the question is: how do we ensure that we do this on Australian terms?

When it comes to data centres, the Prime Minister, some months ago, already articulated the need for mandatory standards and the need for social licence to be retained when it comes to copyright. We are consulting. We are engaging. But let us not pretend that we do not already have a challenge, where Australian creative content is being used without protection in different jurisdictions. (Time expired)