This is a proof (draft) Hansard, not the final version.
The Parliament had not yet published the final text for this day when we fetched it, so the wording, who said what and the results of divisions may differ from the final text.
Scott Buchholz Wright, Liberal Party
12:50 pm
I start by offering my comments to my fellow Australians about the current crisis that finds itself at the feet of every Australian at the moment, with reference to those that are exposed to fuel prices and those that are exposed to the lack of fuel. I think, at the last count, there were over 900 service stations without fuel. Perplexing for some to think as to how this could happen when we are being told that we have the storage capacity in hand and that this is nothing other than panic buying by the Australian public—my task here with this grievance debate is not to come in here and join a conga line of tit-for-tat, blaming one or the other for the perilous situation that we find ourselves in, but to have a sobering conversation with the Australian public about what the coming months and potentially the coming years look like.
In the last 48 hours, I have spoken with a number of constituents in my electorate who are reaching out to voice their concerns, and there is no better place than a grievance debate to raise those concerns and share them with the Australian public. I'm sure those on the other side of the chamber are receiving exactly the same calls. I have a fuel distributor who sends nine B-doubles to the fuel terminal a week. He supplies 450 farmers. He supplies two shire councils. He supplies six service stations and three bus companies. Last week, he was down to two B-double loads, and the distributors have told him that there's no fuel this week. Can you imagine what his business model looks like when it comes to clients ringing him right in the middle of a harvest time—those growers that I said that he represents. We got some type of idea of what an essential service looked like during COVID. If those farmers don't have the diesel that they require to plant the food to put on the plates of Australians in a month's time—the crisis that we face now of not having diesel falls into insignificance when we don't have food to put on the shelves. I just make that point I make these points to outline what we need to be doing as a government to make sure that we are trying to inoculate ourselves from every scenario.
Last week, there were two bills that were introduced into the House. One was to deal with the fuel crisis. One was a bill to deal with increasing the fines for the ACCC on regulators or fuel suppliers who may be taking the opportunity to gouge. The second part of the bill that came through the House concurrently allowed the transport sector to pass on the fuel levy. Some seven out of 10 transport operators may have entered into long-term contracts with suppliers. I know, when I was a transport operator, I had rise-and-fall provisions in my contracts that allowed me, when fuel went up, to pass that through and subsequently, when fuel went down, to make sure that those savings would go back to head contractors, multinationals.
I do understand that there's a whole swathe of independent operators that don't have that complexity and that level of sophistication in their contract agreements and that are taking the opportunity now that fuel has near on doubled just to simply park their trucks up. We've all heard the phrase that without trucks, without the transport sector, our nation stops. That is a dire situation, and it's incumbent on us to find solutions to keep our transport sector moving and to keep our truckers rolling.
I also have had conversations in this place with risk assessors, those who will make assessments on this current conflict and assess how this affects their business, the financial markets and the insurance markets into the future. Take, for example, bond rates and what they look like into the future. Assessors will make short-term, mid-term and long-term risk assessments. God willing, the short-term risk assessment is that this is over and done in a matter of weeks, if not months, the Strait of Hormuz in the Middle East is reopened, and we see some return to normality. We as a country have little or no influence over that geopolitical landscape. As a result, we then take a look at what the mid-term risk looks like: troops on the ground and a 12-month insurgence. And the worst-case scenario that the risk assessors are genuinely making provisions around is a four-year conflict. When they make predictions of a four-year conflict, they're doing that around previous conflict timeframes, such as Iraq and Afghanistan. We all remember Russian President Putin's words that he'd be in and out of Ukraine in eight days. Three years later, they are still heavily entrenched with each other's conflict. So there's a real possibility that this could last for years. The risk assessments are being done now, so let's take that as our starting point.
Can I assure those farmers who, as I said at the beginning of my speech, were ringing and telling me about their problems with a lack of fuel that fuel is going to be the least of their problems if this is going on for two or three or four years. Fuel is going to be the least of their problems if they've got fuel in the trucks but they don't have fertiliser, which is another fuel-based commodity, a petroleum by-product that comes predominantly from gas through the urea that we need for nitrogen—a component which has revolutionised the agricultural sector with its yields. Fertiliser now is the single most valuable commodity when we're doing our inputs into a crop. The other concern we have is AdBlue.
If we're still having this conversation in two, three or four years, as I said to my growers, 'The inputs that you're worried about today, like fuel, will fall into insignificance when the inflationary effects of fuel, fertiliser, AdBlue and all the other costs are felt.' Remember, when you go to a shop and buy something that's packaged in plastic, your fruit and vegetables, all that plastic and packaging is a by-product of fuel. So, when fuel goes up, you won't just feel it at the bowser; you'll feel it across every commodity when you go to the checkout. That inflationary effect that will flow through has the potential, on our current trajectory—and Westpac are making these projections already for the short term, for the next 12 months—for interest rates in Australia alone to move three basis points by the end of the year. That's sobering. So, if this continues and you're doing three basis points a year, that's close to four per cent, with some ebbs and flows, over three or four years. Can you imagine the effect that that will have on the Australian public?
It is incumbent on us as a government to not be doing everything possible but to be acting now. A wise man once said, 'The smartest time to plant a tree was 20 years ago, to be able to sit in the shade of it.' The smartest time now to be building the infrastructure that we need to be able to manufacture our fertiliser and to manufacture and be independent of our own AdBlue supplies and our fuel sovereignty is now. I want to work with the government on bringing solutions that protect every single Australian.
Tom French Moore, Australian Labor Party
1:00 pm
I rise on the motion that grievances be noted, and I want to raise a grievance about fuel security and, more specifically, about the way in which those opposite have chosen to conduct themselves in this moment. Australians can see what's going on globally—instability in the Middle East, pressures on supply chains and increased demand. We, the Australian people, all feel it every time you pull into a servo. It's not abstract. It's not theoretical. It is a real supply challenge. And, in that environment, this government has acted. The Minister for Climate Change and Energy, Chris Bowen, hasn't been sitting back and issuing commentary. He's been intervening directly to keep fuel moving. That includes forcing suppliers to get fuel into regional and independent servos that were running dry—not asking nicely, just making it happen. When supply tightens, you don't just hope the market sorts itself out. We're getting ahead of the problem because we want to step in and make sure Australians aren't left stranded. Alongside that, we've released fuel from stockholdings to boost supply, adjusted standards to bring more fuel into the system and coordinated nationally across governments and industries. That is what managing a supply shock looks like.
The grievance is what we're seeing from those opposite. Instead of contributing constructively, unlike the member for New England, they've defaulted to a familiar routine. They're like that kid from school that didn't do the work in the group assignment, was nowhere to be found when it actually mattered and then somehow rocked up at the end, hand out, ready to take all the credit. The problem is that this is not the first time we've seen this. When they were in government, when they actually had responsibility, what did they do? They oversaw the closure of four out of the six refineries in this country, and we were told it wouldn't matter. Now we know exactly how much that matters. Once that capability is gone, you're more exposed, you are more dependent on imports and you are far more vulnerable when global conditions turn against you. They've also talked about minimum stockholdings but never delivered them. And, in what may be one of the most remarkable decisions in energy policy in this country's history, they spent close to $100 million storing fuel not here in Australia but in the United States, 14,000 kilometres away. That is not a back-up plan. That's a postcard. This is where the minister has been very clear. In a crisis, you don't just observe the market, you make sure it works.
I didn't come into this place as someone who worked behind a desk. I was a sparky. I worked all across Western Australia. I've worked in the Pilbara. I've worked in Kalgoorlie. I've worked all across the state. I can tell you that the systems don't care who takes credit. They either work or don't. They either have reliable inputs or fail. Fuel is one of those inputs. And, when that input is disrupted, the consequences don't stay contained. They spread through freight, through construction, through supply chains and ultimately into the cost of living. That's why this matters. That's why fuel has been directed into regional areas. It's why supply has been increased. It's why coordination has been stepped up—because the alternative is what we saw under those opposite, a system left exposed, hoping global security would remain stable. And, as we are seeing now, that is not something you can rely on.
This isn't just about fuel. This is a pattern. The Liberal Party has spent years claiming to be the better economic managers, but that reputation rested on the work done by Labor—the hard reforms, the structural changes and the difficult decisions taken under leaders like Paul Keating. Labor does the heavy lifting. These guys just inherit the benefits and then claim the title, and now we're seeing the same thing play out again.
This matters in places like Moore because fuel isn't optional. It affects people commuting across Perth's northern suburbs, small businesses trying to keep costs down and supply chains bringing goods into our community. While Moore is metropolitan, it is connected to regional WA, to freight, to agriculture and to the broader community. When fuel supply tightens, the impact doesn't stay in one place. It flows through everything.
The grievance is simple: those opposite had the opportunity to strengthen fuel security, and they didn't. Now they seek to criticise the work required—
An opposition member interjecting
to manage that reality, and true to form—
An opposition member interjecting
You cannot fix a fuel—
Mary Aldred Monash, Liberal Party
Please address your comments through the chair.
Tom French Moore, Australian Labor Party
You cannot build an oil refinery in four years.
Mary Aldred Monash, Liberal Party
Order! Please address your comments through the chair.
Tom French Moore, Australian Labor Party
Apologies. They now seek to criticise the work required to manage that reality, and, true to form, they've turned up at the end of the assignment to take credit for the work they didn't do. Meanwhile, this government is getting on with the job, keeping fuel moving, keeping the system functioning and making sure Australians are protected as much as possible from the global show. What we're seeing from those opposite right now is an absolute performance. We have a serious attempt to deal with a complex problem, and they come with all the energy and indignation of schoolkids insisting that someone has copied their homework. That might be convincing if they'd actually done any of the homework in the first place.
Australians understand what is going on here. While those opposite have been busy making claims, this government has been focused on three things: understanding the situation in real time, coordinating across the system and acting early to keep supply moving.
That starts with information. You cannot manage fuel security if you don't know what's happening across the network, what's in storage, what's moving through terminals and where disruptions are emerging. That is why this government has strengthened the information coming in: weekly reporting, new powers to require data and direct visibility over supply and distribution. If you're flying blind in a situation like this, you're already behind.
The second piece is coordination. Fuel doesn't move in neat, isolated boxes. It moves across jurisdictions, across industries and across supply chains that are tightly linked, so our response reflects that. That is why we've brought together industry, transport operators and the agricultural sector. That's why we've activated the national coordination mechanisms. In a disruption, what matters is making sure fuel gets to where it is needed most.
The third piece is acting early, not waiting for the crisis to fully land. We're not scrambling once shortages appear but stepping up early to expand supply and ease pressure. That's what these measures, like releasing stockholdings and adjusting standards, are all about. It's not theory. They're not announcements. These are, again, practical steps to keep the system moving. If your fallback is on another continent, you're not strengthening the system; you're distancing it from where it's actually needed.
When we hear those opposite now claim urgency, it's reasonable to ask: Where was that urgency when those decisions were being made? Where was the focus on resilience, on capability and on preparedness? You don't get to ignore those questions and then claim ownership of the solution now. You certainly don't get to accuse others of copying your work when what you left behind was not a plan but a gap. Right now, the difference is clear. On this side, there is a focus on information and on acting early to protect Australians. On the other side, there is a lot of noise, a very loud insistence that the work being done now was their idea all along. And Australians can see through that. They know the difference between preparing for a challenge and reacting to it after the fact. When it comes to fuel security, that difference matters, because this debate isn't about credit; it's about whether the country is ready when it counts. That is exactly what this government is focused on delivering.