House debates Matters of Public Importance
Manufacturing Industry
Milton Dick Speaker
3:23 pm
I've received a letter from the honourable the Leader of the Nationals and I've also received a letter from the honourable member for Hunter proposing that definite matters of public importance be submitted to the House for discussion. As required by standing order 46, I get to choose the matter which is, in my opinion, the most urgent and important. Today, that is the one proposed by the honourable the Leader of the Nationals, namely:
This Government devastating industries and manufacturing across Australia.
I therefore call upon those honourable members who approve of the proposed discussion to rise in their places.
More than the number of members required by the standing orders having risen in their places—
David Littleproud Maranoa, National Party, Shadow Minister for Agriculture
During the election campaign we heard ad nauseam about a future made in Australia. There were $38 billion worth of programs to say that we're going to make everything here in Australia. It is nothing more than an expensive slogan. The lived experience of industry across this country today is that it has now cost them over $3 billion in bailouts to try and keep industry alive, because this government has worked on slogans rather than fixing the fundamentals of what makes us competitive and what keeps industry going. It's not just heavy industries in Port Pirie, Mount Isa and Whyalla; it's also the new emerging industries like artificial intelligence and data centres where you need baseload power and cheap, affordable energy that will be there when you need it to be able to compete. When you are blessed with all the resources here on this continent, why do we have the most expensive energy in the world?
That is why we saw, even yesterday, at the National Press Club, BlueScope send another warning to this government about their operations—the thousands of people that BlueScope employs across this country, along with those smelters—that are now at risk. They are simply being bailed out, with dollar after dollar, year after year, because we have not had the courage to face up to fixing the fundamentals. And this government is continuing to go down that path of an all-renewables approach.
There is no industrial country the size of Australia that has gone down an all-renewables path. There are a couple that have had a red-hot crack at it: Portugal and Spain. They got to 77 per cent of renewables, and their entire grid went out for over a week and a half. They had to draw on continental Europe to be able to get their baseload power up and the turbines for their energy generation going again, to give them some hope and to keep their economy going. That is the reckless race that this government is taking us down. But it comes at a cost. It comes at a significant cost. Only this week, Rainforest Reserves, which is not necessarily a card-carrying member of the National Party, let me give you six to four on that, the environmental group, has, for the first time—because the minister for climate change has not even bothered to model, has not even worried about, what sort of impact it would have on not only the cost to your energy bill but also the environment—has done the meticulous work, and it has been costed at $1.382 trillion.
An opposition member: How much?
Trillion—$1.382 trillion! Just cast your mind back to the election campaign and the scare campaign that the Prime Minister ran, talking about a $600 billion nuclear plan. At least we had Frontier Economics model ours—
Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this
Government Members:
Government members interjecting—
David Littleproud Maranoa, National Party, Shadow Minister for Agriculture
You may laugh. You actually use them in the same way that we do. In fact, they are a respected economic house. They put our plan, which had 38 per cent of our grid as nuclear energy, a bit over 50 per cent renewables and the balance as gas and coal, at $331 billion, not $600 billion. But, even at $600 billion, that's less than half of what every Australian is going to have to pay of the $1.382 trillion. That's why we have a government that does not have the courage to face up to the Australian people and tell them exactly what the cost is.
What is the cost that the Australian people are prepared to pay? It's not just as governments but also private enterprise, because guess what happens? Private enterprise—they'll come in here and use some mealy words and say, 'We're going to incentivise business to be part of this.' But guess what? Business has to be paid back. Business has to get a return, and guess who pays? The good old taxpayer. You get that in your bill every quarter. That is the lived experience of Australians—not just heavy industry, with the frightening situation that they are in of potentially losing their jobs. It's what every Australian sees every quarter, every time they open their energy bill. They should see the Prime Minister's and the energy minister's face on that bill every time they open it. Remember that the government promised us that their bills were going to go down $275 this year, based off their 2022 bill. No, they've gone up by $1,300. And the RBA governor belled the cat when she said, 'Not only is that baked in, but it's going to continue to go up.'
But there's also the impact, not just the costs that business is saying they can't afford and are uncompetitive. The human toll for Mount Isa alone—17,000 people would have been impacted by that smelter going under. That's the human toll of the decisions that this government is making. They're putting people out of their jobs. At some point, the subsidies are going to have to stop, because you know what? What this mob doesn't understand is that unfortunately Australian taxpayers' money runs out. It's not for them to keep spending. It's for them to understand that they need to fix the fundamentals to keep industry going to allow them to pay the bills in this country.
When you think about the impact on our environment—over 430,000 hectares of landscape, both prime agricultural land and native environment, are going to be ripped up. We're destroying the very thing we're saying we're there to protect, but we're also tearing up this nation's food security and we are pushing up your food prices, all for an ideology. The greens actually understand—not these Greens but the green conservation movement—but the ideology of this government doesn't.
They're also talking about 45,000 kilometres of new roads. Well, I'm from western Queensland. We'd just like some potholes filled in on the highways we've already got. We don't need to build new roads. And let me tell you, that $1.382 trillion doesn't include the transmission lines, and it doesn't include the battery program that the minister talked about today that 70,000 or 80,000 are signed up to. Just a little number for the minister to understand—while there might be 70,000 or 80,000 households taking it up, there are over 17 million households in this country, and most of them can't afford the other two-thirds you've got to fork out for a battery, so bully for them. The poor old pensioner out there is never going to afford a battery, but they're going to have to continue to pay their electricity bill.
It also doesn't include the extra 15 gigawatts of gas that needs to be developed and put into the grid. So those opposite understand, your energy bill is determined by your highest input cost. The highest input cost is gas, and the more you have to put gas in, the higher your energy bill goes up. It is an important part of every energy grid, but it shouldn't be greater than what it needs to be, because it's going to push your energy bills up. These are the economics, the physics, the environmental and the social impacts of this reckless race to an all-renewables approach.
Let me tell you, there are a couple of chestnuts coming along on top of this that the Australian public need to be aware of. We heard from Senate estimates today that there is not only a $300 carbon tax coming our way but also this thing called the safeguards mechanism that has been weaponised by those opposite. It says to the top 219 emitters that they must reduce their emissions by five per cent every year between now and 2023 or they can utilise technology. The safeguards mechanism was put in place by the coalition because it was about utilising technology, rather than taxes, to get to an emissions reduction. But it wasn't a stick; it was a carrot. This government has imposed a stick. If you can't impose a technology that doesn't even exist, you have to buy offsets. So that five per cent every year is a cost that gets put onto the consumer, and guess what happened? This government is now saying that next year they're going to broaden the safeguards mechanism, which means businesses across the economy are going to have to pay a tax that will be passed on to the Australian consumer.
But don't worry. They've done a deal with business industry groups, and they're going to say: 'We know that's going to make industry in this country even more uncompetitive, so we're going to square the ledger. We're going to bring in a tariff.' The technical term is a carbon border adjustment mechanism, but, for us, it's a tariff. It's a tariff on like products that are being imported into this country so that we can make our industry competitive. But guess what? That's inflationary. That means that everything, like cement, steel and aluminium and also things like fertiliser and agricultural inputs, therefore herbicides and pesticides, goes up in price. That means your food bill goes up. That means your ability to build a house goes up. That means that you pay more.
This is where their ideologies are meeting the practical realities of what Australians are having to bear. This is where there needs to be some courage. This is where there needs to be some acknowledgement from those opposite that, while ideologically it seemed great and was a great idea at the time, the reality is that the lived experience of every Australian will be that, whether they be employers or at the household level, they will be paying the bill. They would be paying a bill that is not necessary. If we drew on the resources of this country and had an energy grid that did not rely on just one energy source but a number that gave baseload power and the ability to compete internationally, then Australians wouldn't have to fear for their jobs. There would be a future for artificial intelligence. There would be a future for data centres in this country.
But, unfortunately, we are going down a path that is taking this nation back to being a poorer one where Australia will be left behind. That is an ideology that has not met the practical reality and the lived experiences that Australians feel today or will feel into the future. The day of reckoning is coming very soon.
Matt Keogh Burt, Australian Labor Party, Minister for Veterans’ Affairs
3:33 pm
You could power the city of Perth, the city of lights, on the hypocrisy contained in the topic of the MPI today. Of course, after listening to that contribution from the Leader of the Nationals, not only is he walking out; the students that are worried about their future in this country walked out as well. They couldn't even last the whole 10 minutes of listening to the Leader of the Nationals.
Why is that? It's because of their record in government. No government did more to devastate the Australian manufacturing sector than the last Liberal government. They sent the car industry packing. They sent more than 100,000 manufacturing jobs offshore under their watch. They were always talking down industry with their extreme anti-manufacturing agenda, and it didn't stop there.
When we came into government to establish our Future Made In Australia agenda to rebuild manufacturing in this country under the great leadership of the former minister—the member for Chifley over there—what did they do? They opposed the $23 billion that we were putting into manufacturing through Future Made in Australia. They voted against energy bill relief for our manufacturing sector, and, when we brought in tax cuts for every single manufacturing worker in Australia, they decided they wanted to have an early election about it.
During the last parliament, when the current Leader of the Opposition was their industry spokesperson, she used to go around calling Australian manufacturing a graveyard. I wonder why that was! They went into the last election with a policy to rip up the National Reconstruction Fund—the biggest investment in domestic manufacturing in a generation—after they'd already slayed our manufacturing base here in Australia.
It's crazily brave from their tactics committee, on the basis of the shambles they were in when they were in government as a coalition, to bring up this topic as the MPI now. But there is a lone wolf—sorry, I mean a lone voice—on the other side that is prepared to bring a challenge to the current liberal orthodoxy of industry policy. Of course, I refer to none other than the member of Canning. Draping himself over a 1969 Ford Falcon like he was Liza Minnelli, he said that it's 'an Aussie car made by Aussie workers for the Australian people' on his Facebook video. He said, 'I want to see us making complex things again, because I'm ambitious for my country.' He should probably say that to the member for Mitchell, who's actually their industry spokesperson. But something tells me they're taking a break from each other at the moment.
No matter what the member for Canning or the member for Mitchell, or even the Leader of the Opposition, says or doesn't say, nothing can erase their record. They have never supported manufacturing and, despite the bluster from one of their MPs for his own political purposes, they never will. But it was at least nice to see the member for Canning effectively endorsing Labor's approach to supporting making more here in Australia.
The contrast of the record of those opposite when in government to the record of this government could not be more stark, which is what makes this MPI topic even the more foolish. If you want to support manufacturing, you need to do more than just shoot off some Facebook reels in a driveway. You need to actually show up, just like the industry minister did this week in Mount Isa—working with industry and the Queensland government for an investment of $600 million to secure the future of regional jobs in North Queensland and ensuring 600 jobs. That's just like what this government did in Whyalla in South Australia and with the Nyrstar plan in Tasmania. And this is about more than just those jobs and those regional economies.
The minister said this morning—I heard him on the radio—that these are vital industries for Australia's national interest, critical to our economic future. The Mount Isa copper smelter, for example, makes half of our copper output. The Whyalla steelworks make most of the rebar for construction. These industries need a strong champion at their side to support them through difficult global conditions. That's exactly what the Albanese government is, and we are seeing results. There are 7,500 more manufacturing businesses now than there were in 2020. This means more good jobs and more investment opportunities.
We need to make the Australian economy more productive. That means we need a thriving manufacturing sector, and of course we've been doing that. We've been backing the manufacturing sector since day one, with $15 billion through the National Reconstruction Fund, $500 million through the Future Made in Australia Innovation Fund for clean energy manufacturing—including batteries—and $400 million through the Industry Growth Program. We're setting up a new $1 billion economic resilience program through the National Reconstruction Fund.
There's $2 billion for the green aluminium production credit and a $5 billion net zero fund. But it doesn't stop there. Of course there's defence as well. Nowhere is it more true than in developing our defence capabilities that we invest in our manufacturing here in Australia. Take, for example, the recent announcement of the Ghost Shark project, which was launched by the Deputy Prime Minister. It's a $1.7 billion investment in developing long-range undersea autonomous vehicles to be made right here in Australia. It's great Australian technology built by Australian skilled workers to help bolster our national security.
As I stood with the Prime Minister and the Deputy Prime Minister only a few weeks ago in Henderson Western Australia, we announced a further $12 billion investment in developing the Henderson maritime complex—which will be, in total, a $24 billion project. That will see and support the building of landing craft for Army, the building of new frigates and of course our AUKUS capabilities in Western Australia. It will see Defence industry become the second biggest industry in Western Australia. But those opposite didn't have a plan for Defence industry; they just had talking points. Just like their overall defence policy more generally, it was all headline and no substance—no real commitment to Australian content when they were in government, and no real commitment to developing our sovereign capability.
Then we come to agriculture, which of course the member for Maranoa is very invested in. No government has done more for improving market access for our agricultural sector than the Albanese government and of course the trade minister, Senator Don Farrell. The value of production in agriculture, fisheries and forestry will pass $100 billion this financial year. We've reopened access to China. That's $20 billion worth of trade. And of course we've finalised a number of free-trade agreements. We've opened 29 new markets. We've protected 81 of our markets in the face of trade threats. We've restored 17 markets where trade was lost and made 107 improvements to existing markets, all to help our farmers and producers.
We are a government that backs manufacturing through thick and thin. We are prepared to invest, and we are prepared to support—something that, based on the speech we just heard, those in the opposition want to walk away from, from supporting our industries. We make sure that we protect our vital national interest and our national security by supporting our manufacturing industries and supporting our national capability. Those opposite have nothing to offer except a track record of failure.
The Albanese government is rebuilding Australia's industrial base. The government is building a more productive and resilient economy. That means good jobs for all Australians. We will never get that from the coalition.
Andrew Willcox Dawson, Liberal National Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Manufacturing and Sovereign Capability
3:41 pm
Labor is destroying industry and manufacturing in this country. While I welcome the intervention into Glencore, it is like putting a bandaid on a bullet wound: you are doing nothing to fix the fundamentals of helping industry within this country.
Back in July, this side of the House called for a Senate inquiry into the health of the metal manufacturing industry within Australia, because we knew they were facing some headwinds. But what happened? Those opposite teamed up with their mates the Greens—that old holy alliance—and voted it down. Who in their right mind would not want to work out—or actually listen to industry, speak to industry about—what they need to make sure they have a strong future?
Since then, what have we seen? We've seen more than $3 billion needed for bailouts: $2.4 billion in Whyalla, $135 million for Nyrstar and now, just recently, a $600 million bailout for Glencore. That will hopefully save 600 jobs. Now, I'm supportive of the jobs, but that is $1 million per person. And probably the biggest indictment on those opposite is that Alcoa, in the resources minister's electorate, is closing down. If you can't even save one of your own, in your own electorate—it's closing down.
When I speak to industry and manufacturers, the No. 1 issue that they have is energy. Energy prices are going through the roof. They're skyrocketing. This is after, in 2022—everyone can remember this—the Prime Minister stood up and said, 'You will be $275 better off if you vote for me.' That wasn't a slip of the tongue; it was a promise repeated 97 times. But what's happened? Household budgets have ended up $1,300 worse off. And manufacturing and the industry have been much worse off.
Blue River Ice, in my electorate—their bill has gone up by more than $10,000 a month. It is unaffordable for heavy industry. Heavy industry is very capital intensive, so they need to operate 24 hours a day. For those opposite, something that needs to operate 24 hours a day needs baseload power that is actually produced 24 hours a day, not a reckless race to renewables, which is what they are backing, that produce power only when the sun shines or the wind blows. How much sun shines at night? None at all.
Battery storage—a great question from those opposite, and I take the interjection. How does heavy industry run on batteries? Ba-bow! It doesn't. That's how simple it is—it doesn't. What about gas? Gas remains over $10 a gigajoule. We've got plenty of gas in Australia. Why don't we drill for more, explore more and actually increase gas supply? Everybody knows, when you increase supply, the price can go down.
The next thing that manufacturers talk to me about is labour shortages. We need to bring in some skilled workers. This should touch a nerve with those on the other side—
Rob Mitchell McEwen, Australian Labor Party
Immigration—you don't like immigration!
Andrew Willcox Dawson, Liberal National Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Manufacturing and Sovereign Capability
Thank you—your migration policy. The big Australia policy of the Albanese Labor government is bringing in the wrong people. You need to be bringing in electricians, plumbers and gasfitters—people who can actually provide rather than that, when you get a ticket to Australia, it is like winning Gold Lotto. We should be able to pick the right people to bring in and look after our country—you need to wake up and smell the roses, folks—rather than necessarily just chasing the people who will vote for you. Think about Australia for once rather than yourselves.
Of course, the other issue is the supply chains. There was $7.2 billion for the Bruce Highway, another promise by Labor, before the election. It has just been realised in Senate estimates that there's only $432 million available over the next three years. Unbelievable! Rather than having $7,200 million, there is $432 over the next three years. What a circus! In the space industry—in 2023, you stripped $1.2 billion out of that. When is the Albanese Labor government going to get behind manufacturing and support it? (Time expired)
Zaneta Mascarenhas Swan, Australian Labor Party
3:46 pm
I am proud to stand here as a member of the great Australian Labor Party. I am also the daughter of migrants. My dad was a metalworker. My dad worked on the workshop floors. In fact, my dad worked alongside Bobs, Garys, Vladimirs and Mohammeds because that's what manufacturing looked like 50 years ago. And guess what? When I go to the heart of Swan, that's what workshops look like today, but there are also more women. It's super exciting. Something that might be interesting to follow, for those at home and on the other side of the benches—the Labor Party has done so much work in this area.
I have grown up in the mining industry. Growing up in the industry, one of the things you see is what happens when you have boom-bust economies. Do you know what happens? People lose their jobs, and jobs are very important. What is this number—1,135,500? That's the number of jobs created under the federal Labor government since May 2022. How do you know if industry is strong? It's if people have jobs. Which government has created the most of jobs? It is the great Australian Labor Party. We do that because we back industry. But not only do we back industry; we're looking at jobs for the future. We are looking at jobs in 20, 30 and 40 years, and we are doing that by reimagining what the future of Australia looks like. We are doing that through the National Reconstruction Fund because when we diversify our economy we become more resilient. We have quality, secure jobs that can help people for decades to come. This is something that I am deeply passionate about. One of the reasons for that is that I remember being in WA 15 years ago when we had $170 billion worth of LNG projects happening in the North West Shelf and not one of those projects was being developed in WA. Hundreds of engineers lost their jobs, and the workshops were empty.
At that time, it was a state Liberal government. They did not believe in local jobs, local manufacturing and looking at the way we could actually create industry, right? So what we next saw was a state Labor government, which decided they were into beautiful craftsmanship. There is a beautiful bridge called the Matagarup Bridge, out near the football stadium in Burswood. They were like, 'Should we build it overseas or locally?' We built it locally, and it is a stunning example of craftsmanship. I recommend that people go check it out. Then they also brought railcar manufacturing to WA, and you know what? What a great idea. Federal Labor then came up with our vision for manufacturing—the National Reconstruction Fund—and we are imagining what we can do.
Some people think that we used to make complex things. I hate to say it, the nerd in me—yes, I am a scientist and an engineer—knows we already do some really complex things. We came up with the idea of the cochlear implant, and we are manufacturing it. We came up with the technology for polymer banknotes. We are exporting it. Also—to be a total nerd—there's the Square Kilometre Array in Western Australia, where we're looking at the stars. It is incredibly impressive. But what I'm saying is we need to do more than that, and that is what the National Reconstruction Fund is about. It's about looking at the way that we can continue to build industry and do this for the nation. This is a nation-building exercise, and Labor is doing this. The other thing that I'd say is—we were talking about energy before. My day job before I was elected to the federal parliament was to give people energy advice. The cheapest form of energy is actually wind and solar.
Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this
Hon. Members:
Honourable members interjecting—
Zaneta Mascarenhas Swan, Australian Labor Party
Yes, how about that? Crazy! I agree that we need to have cheaper energy, and the cheapest form of energy at the moment is renewable energy. We need to continue to look at how we can do this. Also, baseload? That's a fantasy. That's not the way our modern electricity systems are going to look. That's just a fallacy. Put that out there. But I'm really excited about the energy future for Australia, our industrial base and the way that we can be a nation that builds things for the future. The truth is that the pathway to net zero emissions cannot happen without Australia. We've got the resources below the ground. We've got the resources above the ground. This is such an exciting opportunity, and I recommend that the coalition join with us. If you think manufacturing it cool, support the National Reconstruction Fund.
Michelle Landry Capricornia, National Party
3:51 pm
Regional Australia is the beating heart of our nation, the home of the industries that keep this country not just running but thriving. It's the miners, manufacturers and farmers who power our economy, feed our people and build our future. When regional Australia is strong, our whole nation is strong, but, under the Albanese Labor government, these industries and the communities that depend on them are under siege. This is a government that governs for the cities not the regions, a government driven by ideology not common sense and a government whose policies are devastating productivity, driving businesses to the wall and threatening the livelihoods of hardworking Australians.
Labor's agenda is eroding that foundation—from their reckless all-renewables policy and fantasy 2035 emissions target to their cuts to regional infrastructure and skyrocketing energy costs. Labor has become the single biggest risk to Australia's economy. In the June quarter of 2025, manufacturing contributed just 5.1 per cent of GDP, the lowest level on record. Australia now ranks amongst the lowest in the OECD for manufacturing share. Yet more than 900,000 Australians still work in manufacturing. These businesses have endured COVID, supply chain shocks and soaring costs. They're not asking for hand-outs; they're asking for a fair go. They want affordable, reliable energy, a competitive tax system and a government that rewards effort not bureaucracy. Instead they've got the opposite.
Labor went to the 2022 election promising to cut power bills by $275 by 2025. Instead bills are up 39 per cent. That's $1,300 more than promised. While the minister tells the media how important gas is for manufacturing, he fails to mention that Australian industry is paying $10.30 a gigajoule for gas compared to $3 in the United States. Labor's treatment of regional Australia is nothing short of disgraceful. For the one in three Australians who live outside our capital cities, Labor's record is defined by neglect, incompetence and betrayal. Families across the regions are doing it tough. They're facing soaring costs, housing shortages and dwindling access to health care and child care. What has Labor done? Cut and delayed billions in regional funding. Labor's first budget slashed over $10 billion in regional programs and $30 billion in projects across the country. They axed or gutted the Building Better Regions Fund, the Stronger Communities Program, the Local Roads and Community Infrastructure Program and the regional accelerator fund. I've had to fight tooth and nail to keep vital economy-boosting projects alive—like the Rockhampton ring road, which faced Labor's chopping block, and safety upgrades for the Phillips Creek Bridge in the Bowen Basin.
Even now, Labor is wilfully delaying the $23 million Rocky sports stadium, a project that's fully funded and construction ready. This project has sat on the minister's desk for a year waiting for approval. I wrote to the minister in February urging action, but, true to form, Labor has done nothing—no communication, no progress, no respect for the people of Rockhampton. Rocky sports club's Gavin Shuker says the club is ready to go, but the minister's office has left them in limbo. They've jumped through every hoop, and all that's needed is a signature so locals can get to work. Labor's red tape and arrogance are hurting regional Australia. This project should already be supporting jobs and delivering benefits for the community. The minister needs to get moving, sign the variation and let Rockhampton move forward.
While regional projects are held hostage, regional communities are being hit with the full force of Labor's all-renewables ideology. Their reckless 2035 emissions target is based on flawed assumptions. It is uncosted, unrealistic and unfair. The government refuses to reveal what it will cost households, businesses or shops, and Australians are already paying the price. Their race to 82 per cent renewables by 2030 is tearing up farmland and bushland with transmission lines, solar panels and wind turbines. This isn't green; it's destroying the environment in the name renewable energy.
The Nationals believe in balance and affordable and sustainable energy solutions. We believe in regional industry. We believe in sovereignty. While Labor governs for the inner-city elite, the Nationals stand with the worker on the factory floor, the farmer in the paddock and the miner who keeps the lights on. Regional Australia deserves more than bureaucracy and broken promises. It deserves a government that has its back, not one that's tearing it down.
Rob Mitchell McEwen, Australian Labor Party
3:56 pm
You would have thought it was Christmas. It's been a week of division, derision and infighting over there, so what do they do on the last day? They bring in an MPI that embarrasses them even worse. It's like looking at the Mos Eisley Cantina across there when we talk about manufacturing and what's happened.
This government came into office backing manufacturing, and I'm surprised; the member for Capricornia might want to remember the report from the committee that she was deputy chair of. It talked about sustainable, sovereign and smart manufacturing. It was not like they do over there. You see old mate from Canning over there, sitting up the back next to a 1969 XW Falcon and in G paint code! He talks about how he wants to bring back 1969 cars. Even Ford moved on from that. Ford, of course, went through and did XA, C, D, F—right through to the FGX, which was the last car produced in Australia. Why? It was because those opposite told Ford they would not support manufacturing in Australia and were scrapping support for the car industry.
It's been an amazing journey when you sit there and think about Sophie Mirabella—that wonderful human being, I say sarcastically—out there telling all those manufacturing workers and ancillary businesses they were not welcome in this country. They were not. I'm going to quote from something that happened many years ago, from a good friend of mine, the now minister for housing in South Australia who was the member for Wakefield, Nick Champion. He stood up in this place very bravely and said:
In 1947 Joseph Benedict Chifley went to watch the first Holden leave the line at Fishermans Bend.
The question was: was Joseph Benedict Hockey going to watch the last one? That was on the day that the former coalition government went and told the industry to leave. In fact, if I read from a Phil Coorey article—something I don't normally do—it says, 'Hockey dares GM to leave,' and it says the federal government had accused Holden of being the problem. The problem was that, during that time, it was the federal government that knocked off the industry. It wasn't the Labor Party; it was the federal government of the Liberals that went out. The quotes at the time were all about it being a few thousand jobs at Ford or a few thousand jobs over here, forgetting the ancillary industries. I watched manufacturers in my electorate who had been working for decades building automotive parts have to go offshore because the ability to continue making those parts and keeping it profitable with the economies of scale was gone.
These are the things that happened under their watch. There has never been a manufacturing industry that they haven't wanted to get rid of. The only industry they care about is the one that fills the bank books, and that's the mining industry. They've never cared about any sort of manufacturing, whether it be the rag trade or any form of construction, automotive, shoes, tires—the whole lot. Whenever there's a manufacturing industry going offshore, you can guarantee the coalition government has its finger on the button that says 'eject'. That's thousands and thousands and thousands of jobs that people lose. We heard an extraordinary contribution earlier about bringing in workers to build this country. We have a skilled migration list for electricians, construction workers and engineers. All these things have a shortage. You closed the technical colleges that actually made these people get jobs!
Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party
They're excluded on your priority list!
Rob Mitchell McEwen, Australian Labor Party
But what happened under you? I'll give you a simple little thing. One of the key skills they had on their skills list was a yoga teacher. That's the way you build an economy. That's the way you build manufacturing into the future. The hypocrisy of those opposite is just second to none. As we head back on the weekend, we think about all those jobs. I know that when we fly over the old Ford factories, as we head into Melbourne, we'll see a very big empty block of land. We'll see an empty block of land that families had built their lives on, that careers had been built on and where generations of workers had worked hard to deliver Australian made products that they just pushed out the door without a second glance.
It is our government that has continued to fight for manufacturing and push for the products of the future. We see what's happening in the medtech space. We see what's happening in quantum. Wherever you look, the future of manufacturing can be bright in Australia, if you have a government that actually backs it. This is a government that backs it, not only with support but with the money to do it. We see the stuff that's being built in medtech right across this country that will go around the world. It will create better lives for people, and we're doing it here. The biggest issue people had for many years in that situation was not getting support from those opposite. The more things change, the more they stay the same. You can always guarantee that a Liberal-National coalition will never back manufacturing. (Time expired)
Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party
4:02 pm
I remind the member for McEwen why these manufacturing jobs are going offshore right now. The average cost of the average manufacturing product is about 60 per cent energy. If the member for McEwen were listening this week, if he bothered to go down to the National Press Club, he would have heard the CEO of BlueScope Steel. If he were listening two weeks ago, he would have heard the CEO of BHP say that Australia's energy costs today are two to three times those of comparable economies. Both these industry leaders are warning the Australian government that we are going to lose jobs. We're going to lose jobs, and that means we're going to lose workers. We're going to lose GDP because of how your side is managing energy. You're deaf to it. You're deaf to actually killing this country through reckless energy policy that will see jobs fly offshore.
You call it a Future Made in Australia, but it's actually a future bailed out in Australia. Two days ago, the government announced a $600 million bailout of the Mount Isa smelter and Townsville refinery. So far, we've also seen a $2.4 billion bailout of Whyalla and a $135 million bailout of Nyrstar. Why are we getting these bailouts?
Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party
I'll take the interjection. Why are we getting the bailouts? I just got hands like this—not an answer, just hands like this, because that is all the other side has. I'll answer for you. The reason we're getting bailouts is the cost of energy. For those of you who don't understand how that works, Mount Isa copper refinery uses 50 per cent of the energy in North West Power Station—50 per cent of that whole power station goes to Mount Isa. Hold on! I'll explain it to you. I can see you struggling with it but just hang with me. Energy has become so scarce that prices keep rising. That's why it's going up. That's why energy has gone up 40 per cent under your watch. It's because it has become so scarce. If it were abundant, prices would be dropping. Mr Leigh knows it. He's very good at economics. He'll explain it to some of you afterwards, if you like. But because of these energy costs—
Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this
An honourable member interjecting—
Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party
I don't know what gender has to do with it.
Sharon Claydon Newcastle, Australian Labor Party
The member for McEwen has the call, on a point of order, I presume?
Rob Mitchell McEwen, Australian Labor Party
Yes. I think it highly inappropriate the term that was used then, and I ask him to withdraw the comment he made about the minister.
Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party
I called him an expert. I'm not going to withdraw that. I said he was an expert.
Sharon Claydon Newcastle, Australian Labor Party
Just a moment. Hang on—I'm the one who adjudicates here. I'm not entirely sure if I heard the comment, but, if was anything offensive or unparliamentary, I would ask the member for Cook to withdraw it.
Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party
Because of energy costs, Glencore was losing money. What happens is: when energy costs go up and down, those who can't pay the cost stop buying energy. Glencore was about to become one of those businesses that could no longer afford to buy energy. We could have used that $600 million to create more energy, but what have we done? We've used that $600 million to give to Glencore so it can buy more energy. So what's it going to do? Buying 50 per cent of that market, it's going to go and outbid all these other businesses, who actually also need the energy, and send those to the wall.
What could we do? We could actually try and solve the underlying problem. Wouldn't that be novel—to actually solve the underlying problem, the cost of energy. We would lower energy. What we would do is not be relying—
Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this
Government Member:
A government member interjecting—
Simon Kennedy Cook, Liberal Party
As to what the member for Swan said previously, it was a half-truth, and we have to be careful with half-truths because they sound right until you scratch the surface. Solar and wind—yes, they are cheap, but they produce energy when we don't need it. If you knew about smelters—and maybe you do—you'd know they require energy 24/7, when the sun is not shining and the wind is not blowing. They require firmed energy. That's what they require. And actually, unfortunately, that's not what's being provided. That's why those prices have gone up so much, and that's why you have business after business going to the wall. That's why you had the CEO of BlueScope Steel saying, just yesterday, 'Australian manufacturing is at a dangerous crossroad'—right now, under your watch, Member. Is he wrong? He spoke about how energy costs will lead to an industrial decline. He said that last year in Australia we averaged $10.30 a gigajoule. What was it in the US? Three bucks. What was it in Qatar? Two dollars. If we keep on under these guys' reckless energy plan, we will drive this country off an economic cliff. (Time expired)
Sharon Claydon Newcastle, Australian Labor Party
I am just going to ask all members in this chamber to start directing your comments through me in the chair. This idea of yelling out 'you' and 'they' and personalising this debate is completely inappropriate. I'm reminding everybody of this.
Steve Georganas Adelaide, Australian Labor Party
4:07 pm
I'm just astounded by what I've been hearing from the other side—not just the last speaker, the member for Cook, but all the others. Those of you who were here in 2013 would recall quite clearly the coalition's then treasurer goading General Motors-Holden out of Australia. We recall it very well. Being a South Australian and the son of a manufacturing worker who worked on the production line in General Motors-Holden, I found that very offensive at the time. If anyone didn't support manufacturing industry, it was the coalition in government and in opposition. We've seen them oppose every bill that has been brought to this place to support manufacturing. We've seen them oppose the car-manufacturing industry. In my home state, General Motors-Holden alone supported over 40,000 jobs.
If you want to talk about manufacturing being offshored, the cars that were produced here in Adelaide, in Elizabeth, are now being produced in Asia and in Mexico, because of the direct intervention of the then coalition treasurer, Mr Joe Hockey. And the proof of that is that, two days after he made his speech here on the frontbench, Mr Devereux, who was the CEO of General Motors-Holden, came out on the front page of the Advertiser and said, 'We no longer have the support of the coalition government and we're moving offshore.' So, if you want to talk about supporting manufacturing, you should have been supporting the automobile industry. Today, we would have been building electric cars and exporting them around the world had the industry had a little bit of support from the coalition back then.
What I'm seeing in my electorate is many manufacturing jobs being created. We've created 7,000 new businesses since 2022. I've got to say that we want every opportunity for Australian businesses and industry to also participate in this once-in-a-generation manufacturing that's coming our way. In South Australia, we've seen the Defence industry. We've seen AUKUS. We are talking about thousands of jobs—just like my father and thousands of others who worked in the manufacturing industry in South Australia—because we were able to design a car from start to finish, from design to the showroom, with the production of motor vehicles. Thousands of people worked. We're on the cusp of another manufacturing revolution if the opposition supports it. That is, in South Australia, Defence building—not only in South Australia but in Perth, in Queensland and all over the country. Listening to the opposition talk about not supporting businesses et cetera is just beside me.
I know that energy prices are high. I think we all accept that. We want to see lower energy prices, but the coalition spent the last 10 years with 22 different energy policies. How could any industry in renewables or in any energy come to the party and feel confident about the government? We've had to start afresh from the very beginning, because we saw that side with 22 different energy policies. They couldn't come to grips with what the reality was. Again, listening to them again today, I don't think this is a motion about supporting manufacturing. This is again about being denialists about climate change. This is their way of saying, 'We deny climate change.'
They remind me of the Japanese soldiers in World War II that were left in caves and thought that the war was still continuing. They were found many years after, and, when they were discovered, they still wanted to fight. Everyone was going: 'No, it's okay. The war is over. We're in peacetime now.' That's what the opposition is. They still haven't come to terms with the fact that the Australian public has moved on, that we believe in climate change and that we need renewables to ensure that we meet our targets, but also that the more renewables and the more energy companies that are in the foray, the cheaper prices will be. When they come to that realisation, they may be competent and again in a position to sell themselves to the Australian public, but, at this point, I just cannot see what the argument is in terms of manufacturing and in terms of energy cost. They have to ensure that they do everything that they can, just as we are, to support manufacturing but also support renewables, because the more renewables we have in the market, the better off we will be and the cheaper the prices will be. (Time expired)
Sam Birrell Nicholls, National Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Regional Health
4:12 pm
Thank you, Member for Adelaide—I'll try and flesh a bit of that out about energy prices and manufacturing in my presentation. Industry is struggling across Australia, and those of us who have industry in our electorate and go and talk to industries have been told that. Not only are they worried about what is happening now; they're worried about what's going to happen in the future. I'll briefly touch on the very important agricultural industries in my part of the world and across the Murray-Darling Basin that have some real headwinds, because one of their major inputs is irrigation water, and, in the last term of government, the then minister for environment decided that the government would buy a significant proportion of that irrigation water back. Economics 101 is that, when you take something away from what we call a consumptive pool, everything that's left in that consumptive pool gets much more expensive, so those businesses are going to find it harder to buy the irrigation water that they need. That's going to make their businesses less viable, and I predict it will push up food prices for Australian people.
Agriculturalists in the Goulburn Valley need access to affordable and reliable irrigation water. Manufacturing needs energy, and it needs it to be affordable and reliable. As previous speakers on this side have said, there have been recent bailouts in Whyalla, Nyrstar and Glencore, because energy has not been affordable and has not been reliable. Why is that? Well, the answer to where we're going with this comes from a report by the Centre for Independent Studies that I suggest everyone in this parliament read called The renewable energy honeymoon:starting is easy, the rest is hard. It explains the fact that a certain amount of intermittent energy or solar and wind in a grid can be very good. Thirty per cent, roughly, is what they say. Thirty per cent of renewable intermittent energy in a grid can be quite successful.
The people who have what I call 'energy illiteracy' say, 'If 30 per cent is good, 60 per cent must be better, and 90 per cent must be unbelievably good.' I think they've settled on 82. But what this report points out is that the intermittent energy is a very different type of energy in a grid to what we call the baseload generation, which can come from hydro, gas, coal or nuclear. As the penetration of intermittent solar and wind energy gets further into the grid, above 30, up around 50 or 60—and if it ends up at 82 per cent—this report shows that energy becomes much more expensive and less reliable.
They're explaining this because of the way that energy works in the grid, and they're also giving some examples from around the world of people who have tried this. They talk about Spain—they talk about the Iberian blackout that was caused by having too much intermittent power in the grid, causing it to shut down. They talk about Germany, which is going through a de-industrialisation because it relied too much on renewable energy. They talk about Denmark and they talk about California, which have higher energy prices—higher electricity prices. What we're worried about on this side is that, if we ignore this sort of expert advice that explains how the grid works and we continue on with renewable energy up to the point of 82 per cent in the grid, we are going to have a similar price hike and the unreliability that these other countries have experienced. And, unlike Spain, we do not have a neighbour like France with nuclear energy generation to bail us out, which is what they've done. And Denmark has done the same thing in relation to Norway, which is a neighbour that has hydroelectricity.
I just ask everyone: bone up on your literacy when it comes to energy policy. I was actually doing an interview from an apple orchard and I was debating. The member for Warringah said baseload power is an 'antiquated' notion and 'a thing of the past'. And I said, 'These apples—when they get picked, how are they going to be refrigerated if baseload power is an antiquated notion and a thing of the past?' And, sadly, I don't think she's alone in her illiteracy about how the energy grid works when it comes to manufacturing. We need reliable and affordable power to keep industry and keep manufacturing in Australia.
Julie-Ann Campbell Moreton, Australian Labor Party
4:17 pm
Just a few short weeks ago, we all saw a video posted online. What that video showed was a man standing next to a car—a car that was manufactured in this country. The man talked about the fact that he believed that manufacturing was important. I don't think that I've ever seen a video more ironic than that one, because the man standing next to that car was the member for Canning.
I want to use the words of the member for Canning because I think he spoke them best:
The hypocrisy is breathtaking.
The hypocrisy was breathtaking because what we know is that the member for Canning was a member of the coalition—every member sitting across this chamber is a member of the coalition—who, when they were in government, voted for the car industry to go offshore. They sent it offshore. When the car industry was on its knees, they kicked it in the guts and sent those jobs away. Five hundred million dollars was ripped out of the industry, tens of thousands of jobs were no longer there, and critical skills that we need to make the manufacturing industry run were lost.
'Why stop there?' the coalition said. 'There are more manufacturing industries that we can put on the chopping block.' The shipbuilding industry—what did we see in the shipbuilding industry? We saw two big shipyards go overseas—more jobs lost. The train manufacturing industry in my home state of Queensland—what did we see from an LNP government? We saw trains sent overseas and a generational facility in Maryborough face the threat of closure until a Labor government brought those trains back home and brought that manufacturing back home, because we know that manufacturing is absolutely critical. It contributes over $100 billion to our GDP, 22 per cent of our exports are from manufacturing, and a million jobs come from manufacturing.
That's why Labor is investing in manufacturing. We are rebuilding the industry. We're investing in it. We're supporting the workers who work in the industry. And how are we doing that? With $15 billion invested into local manufacturing firms. As we've heard again and again, there are 7,500 more businesses that do the business of manufacturing since 2020. Not only that—we've seen $400 million in industry growth. In my local electorate, in Archerfield, I went to visit a company called Endua. What does Endua get? Endua got an industry growth grant of $4.8 million so that they could work on electrolyser technology. This is advanced manufacturing. This is manufacturing that creates jobs. And not only that—I had the great privilege just the other day to open the new SMART CRC, which is working in medical manufacturing—curing diseases but also creating more manufacturing jobs that can replace the many, many thousands of jobs that the coalition sent offshore. There is $500 million in support for battery manufacture. There is free TAFE, and we all know what they think about free TAFE: they don't support it. But free TAFE is something that supports the skills that we need in manufacturing. And there is over $22 billion for Future Made in Australia.
The coalition woke up today and said, 'Let's pretend that we support manufacturing,' but we remember that they don't, and certainly the people who lost their jobs, the households who lost a wage and the aftermarket, which had money that they relied on every single day ripped out of the economy, remember it too. When you care about something, you don't send it away. When you care about something, you don't defund it. When you care about something, you don't reject opportunities for renewables and battery manufacturing that will make the industry stronger. When you care about something, you don't ship off the workers who drive that industry. What we know about the coalition is that they don't care about manufacturing now, they didn't care about manufacturing then, and they will never care about manufacturing.
Today is 9 October, and it's an important day because today is the anniversary of the very famous misogyny speech given by a great prime minister, Julia Gillard. So, in a hat-tip to her, I finish this speech by saying this: I will not be lectured to about manufacturing by this coalition.
Sharon Claydon Newcastle, Australian Labor Party
The time for this discussion has now concluded.