House debates Statements

Personal Explanation

Thursday, 9 October 2025 House of Representatives

Alison Penfold

Alison Penfold Lyne, National Party

3:20 pm

During question time—

Milton Dick

Milton Dick Speaker

Does the member claim to be misrepresented?

Alison Penfold

Alison Penfold Lyne, National Party

Yes, I do—most callously, Mr Speaker.

Alison Penfold

Alison Penfold Lyne, National Party

During question time, the Prime Minister made an interjection to state that an urgent care clinic in Taree would be a waste. I have written to the Minister for Health, Disability and Ageing twice on the matter and I've spoken with my local primary health network, who have also confirmed that a clinic in Taree is a high priority. If urgent care clinics are a priority for this government, why isn't Taree good enough for one?

Milton Dick

Milton Dick Speaker

Hang on a second, Member for Lyne. I'll hear from the Prime Minister. That is an absolute abuse of standing orders. You were not misrepresented. I don't know what was said. You simply can't get up in this chamber and disagree with something or make a claim. That is a very serious breach of standing orders.

Anthony Albanese

Anthony Albanese Grayndler, Australian Labor Party, Prime Minister

3:21 pm

Mr Speaker, I wish to give a personal explanation.

Milton Dick

Milton Dick Speaker

Does the Prime Minister claim to be misrepresented?

Anthony Albanese

Anthony Albanese Grayndler, Australian Labor Party, Prime Minister

I have been misrepresented—just then by the member for Lyne.

Milton Dick

Milton Dick Speaker

The Prime Minister may proceed.

Anthony Albanese

Anthony Albanese Grayndler, Australian Labor Party, Prime Minister

What I've said is that the coalition say that urgent care clinics are a waste, which is why they never delivered a single one.

Alison Penfold

Alison Penfold Lyne, National Party

That's not what you said. You did not say that!

Milton Dick

Milton Dick Speaker

Order! I want all members to refresh themselves over the break about personal explanations.

Alison Penfold

Alison Penfold Lyne, National Party

No apology!

Milton Dick

Milton Dick Speaker

Member for Lyne, we're moving forward.

Member for Lyne! Do not interject one more time.