House debates Bills
Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2025; Second Reading
Jamie Chaffey Parkes, National Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Agriculture
6:05 pm
I rise to speak on the Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2025. This bill makes a series of technical and administrative amendments to ensure the national joint-replacement register levy operates in line with its original policy intent. Specifically, the bill redefines who is responsible for paying the levy, ensuring that it applies to the current responsible person for the medical device listed on the Prescribed List of Medical Devices and Human Tissue Products, not just the original applicant. This is a sensible and necessary change. It will ensure that the levy keeps pace with commercial changes over time, including where responsibility for a device listing is transferred between companies. The bill also includes validating provisions to mitigate any risk from past levy collections.
The National Joint Replacement Register, or NJRR, plays a vital role in monitoring and improving patient safety and surgical outcomes for Australians receiving joint replacements. The registry, administered by the Australian Orthopaedic Association, collects and analyses data from all relevant hospitals across Australia to help define, improve and maintain the quality of care for joint replacement surgery. The AOA receives Commonwealth funding for aspects of the registry's administration through a grants agreement, and these costs are efficiently recovered through the levy imposed under the Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Act 2009. This bill will ensure that the levy continues to function efficiently and consistently with its original purpose to support the continued collection and analysis of high-quality data on joint replacement outcomes. Therefore, the coalition supports the bill. It is a sensible, technical measure that will improve the operation of the national joint replacement levy. These amendments are administrative. They are consistent with the coalition's longstanding support for efficient, transparent and accountable administration of Australia's health system.
Whilst the coalition supports the bill, it is worth noting that greater action is needed by the Albanese Labor government to ensure that Australian patients have timely access to elective surgeries, such as joint replacement, including ensuring our hospital system has funding certainty going forward and addressing the underlying cause of bed block in our hospitals.
Reports from the states and territories about the ongoing negotiations on the next national health reform agreement—the agreement that determines the Commonwealth contribution to hospital funding—are deeply concerning. The Prime Minister has already broken a key promise on hospital funding. He promised to deliver a new five-year national health reform agreement with the states and territories from 1 July 2025, but he has failed to negotiate, leaving our hospitals in a state of uncertainty at a time when they are facing enormous pressure. Instead of fixing this failure and securing the future of our hospitals, the Prime Minister appears to be sending them backwards. The Prime Minister needs to be honest with the Australian public about whether he intends to break his promise to fund 42.5 per cent of hospital costs by 2030. If he does, that would not just be a broken promise; it would be a betrayal of the patients, families and frontline health workers who rely on certainty in hospital funding.
The Albanese Labor government is clearly failing Australian patients at a time when our health system needs stability and confidence more than ever. Across the country, waiting lists are growing. Hospitals are stretched. Patients are waiting months, sometimes years, for procedures that are critical for their mobility, independence and quality of life. A key part of this challenge is the growing issue of bed block, where older Australians who are ready to be discharged from hospital can't leave because they are waiting for access to an aged-care service. It is not only distressing for patients and their families; it also has a direct impact on the availability of hospital beds and the ability to perform elective surgeries.
The Albanese government must address the underlying cause of bed block, particularly by ensuring that older Australians have timely access to the aged-care support they need. Most urgently, waiting times to access home-care packages have skyrocketed under Labor. Before the election, Labor promised to deliver 83,000 new home-care packages from 1 July 2025. But, instead of following through, they withheld support, even though the sector and the department were ready to deliver on it. As a result, not a single new home-care package was released into the system this financial year.
This failure has devastating consequences. The priority waiting list has now blown out to almost 109,000 older Australians, a 400 per cent increase in just two years. Wait times for the package have tripled. Tragically, almost 5,000 older Australians died in the past year while waiting for a home-care package, while it was only after a coordinated, pressured campaign from the coalition that the government finally caved and agreed to our amendments to guarantee the release of at least 83,000 new home-care packages by the end of this financial year. This includes the immediate release of 20,000 packages and a further 20,000 by the end of the year.
This was a win for older Australians in desperate need of assistance, but it should never have taken such pressure to get there. Labor faced a choice—listen to the coalition and release the packages, or vote against us and continue to deny vulnerable Australians the support they desperately need. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, Minister for Health and Ageing Mark Butler and Minister for Aged Care and Seniors Sam Rae still need to explain to Australia why it took the coalition holding their feet to the fire in the Senate to release this much-needed support. This support should have happened months ago. It is a black mark on this government that they were purposely withholding support for hundreds of thousands of older Australians who desperately needed it.
The coalition has stood up for older Australians across the country—Australians whom this government have abandoned. The money was in the budget. The capacity was there. The only thing standing in the way was Labor. This is a crisis of the government's own making, and there is still more work to be done. Now the test is on the government to provide timely and transparent data to show that they're keeping their promise. Have they released the 20,000 new packages they promised immediately? Will they deliver an additional 20,000 by the end of the year and a further 43,000 by the end of this financial year? This is the minimum that must occur. It must occur on time.
The coalition will continue to fight for older Australians, with one clear goal—that no-one should have to wait for the care that they have been assessed as needing.
Steve Georganas Adelaide, Australian Labor Party
The member will resume his seat. The member for Macarthur on a point of order?
Mike Freelander Macarthur, Australian Labor Party
A point of order on relevance—the member is not speaking to the bill at all.
Steve Georganas Adelaide, Australian Labor Party
I am listening to the member for Parkes and will ask him to keep within the parameters of the legislation.
Jamie Chaffey Parkes, National Party, Shadow Assistant Minister for Agriculture
So, once again, the coalition supports this bill, because it represents practical policy to improve the efficiency and integrity of a key health administration process. But we will continue to hold the Albanese Labor government to account for their failures on hospital funding, access to elective surgery and aged-care delivery. Australians deserve a government that delivers on its promises, not a government that says one thing and does another. Australians deserve access to the support they need, when they need it, whether that's in a hospital, through a home-care package or in residential aged care. I commend the bill to the House.
Mike Freelander Macarthur, Australian Labor Party
6:14 pm
The Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2025 is a very important bill. Joint replacement surgery is one of the remarkable advances of the 20th century in modern health care. For centuries, joint replacement had been attempted and never been successful until Sir John Charnley, a British orthopaedic surgeon, successfully developed the first hip replacement prosthesis in the 1960s with some fairly basic materials. The cup that went into the hip itself was polythene, and a steel ball joint from the hip itself became successful.
These replacements were not perfect. They had a relatively short lifespan, measured in years rather than decades. Gradually, there have been advances in the decades that have followed, and there have also been some setbacks with newer materials that haven't been as successful as they were originally thought to be. There was a specific joint replacement that was used in Australia, developed by a group of orthopaedic surgeons, and found to be faulty after several years. They all had to be replaced, and it was very difficult to trace all the people that had had those specific prostheses, because no registry had been kept.
Then we developed—basically because of that—the national joint-replacement register, which is administered by the Australian Orthopaedic Association because our orthopaedic surgeons are the ones who oversee all the aspects of the registry. This included collecting data from all Australian public hospitals performing joint-replacement surgery, maintaining the data integrity and publishing analysis to track outcomes, identify emerging trends and address potential issues with procedures or implants over the years. Some of the joint replacements in the private hospital system were not registered. This became a problem as, increasingly, this surgery required less time in hospital, became a quicker procedure and was done more in the private system.
This registry is currently funded through a Commonwealth grant agreement. The national joint register is now transitioning to a cost-recovery model supported by the levy. This amendment bill secures this transition, ensures long-term sustainability and reinforces the registry's essential role in safeguarding the quality of joint-replacement care across Australia in both the public system and the private system. This is very important. With an ageing population and with advances in joint-replacement surgery, we are now doing more joints. We're now doing hip and knee replacements, shoulder replacements and even elbow replacements and some in the small joints in the hands and ankles. It's really remarkable to consider the progress over the last 40 or 50 years. By clarifying financial responsibility through this legislation, the bill also improves transparency for a whole range of providers, including insurers, prostheses providers, surgeons and other stakeholders, allowing funding arrangements to evolve while preserving accountability, consistency and operational continuity.
It's not just a cost-effective measure; it really does safeguard Australian patient care. Remember, we're talking about prostheses that can have a lifespan of 25, 30 or even 40 years. This is very important to make sure that follow-up is appropriate and that any problems with the prostheses or even the procedures themselves can be traced through the health system. I really commend the national joint replacement registry and the significant contribution that it's made to our healthcare system and will continue to make in the future. Alone, reporting from the NJRR details that, between early 2023 and 2024, more than 85,000 hip and knee replacement operations were performed annually in Australia. A breakdown of these findings is made available through the national joint replacement registry, the NJRR. Their reporting has shown an increase in this figure over the years, and, with an ageing population, the demand for orthopaedic surgery is expected to significantly increase. The numbers of joints involved will also increase, as will the quality of the replacements. It's very important that we can trace these replacements, trace the lifespan and trace any complications and any need for repeated surgeries.
The NJRR collects data from the hospitals performing prosthesis surgeries every month. A person receiving treatment is recorded once they have been in theatre and are being operated on. This information is received via a paper based system. But a mechanism has now been established to collect this information electronically when it is feasible for the hospital, and most hospitals are now transitioning over to electronic records. The received data collected from individual hospitals is then compared with data provided by state and territory health departments, and the type of prosthesis can also be traced, leading to better data collection. Validation of the NJRR data against the health department unit record data uses sequential multilevel matching processes so all the aspects of the surgery itself, the joint involved and the prosthesis used can be traced. The validation process also identifies procedures that have not previously been notified to the NJRR, with sufficient information being collected via the state system.
The data collection by the NJRR contains the most complete set of data relating to joint replacements in Australia and approaches that of the very best around the world. This is very important, as I said, as we're now moving to better and more refined surgeries in many other joints, not just hips. As I said, knee replacements are now becoming quite common. Shoulder replacements are becoming common. We're doing elbows. We're doing the small joints in the hands. This is a really remarkable development. It's very important not just for those with osteoarthritis due to age or due to overuse but to those who have inflammatory forms of arthritis like psoriatic arthritis or rheumatoid arthritis. The surgery and the treatments are becoming much more sophisticated. The degree of disability post surgery is much less. The time in hospital is much less. These details can be traced through the NJRR.
Beyond administrative and financial impacts the bill amendment contributes to clinical excellence by improving data collection and our understanding of the data we are collecting. The registry's annual reports are widely used by surgeons to monitor their outcomes against national benchmarks, and it is very important that the profession itself is able to monitor its individual surgeons against national benchmarks and their colleagues, and indicate factors relating to device issues such as premature wear in some implants. Identifying factors such as this and the need to revise surgery more frequently can be traced using this data. This certainly improves patient outcomes. It improves the system, it improves the quality of care that we can give and it makes device manufacturers aware as well that their performances are being tracked via data collection, and this can encourage more research and innovation, better prosthesis design and better surgical approaches. It's a really exciting development and again a demonstration that the Albanese Labor government is committed to quality health care and getting equitable access to health care around the country.
Before the establishment of the NJRR in 1993 this reporting was very difficult to trace. It was unclear as to the number of people involved, who was receiving joint replacements, how long they last for, the types of prostheses that were being used and the technique being used to implant them. Even the time of stay in hospital post joint replacement was difficult to ascertain. The time waiting for joint replacement also was difficult to attain, and this now can be looked at. The time waiting prior to surgery after it has been identified can be looked at. This is very important. We know, for example, with fractured hips, fractured neck of femur, once that happens, the results are much better. The shorter time it takes from fracture to joint replacement can dramatically improve results, particularly in elderly patients. We can now track that.
Prior to introducing this legislation the department of health always charged the levy, consistent with the policy intent, but the existing framework requires device sponsors and manufacturers to pay a levy to fund the NJRR's post-market surveillance of joint replacement. This levy is collected by the government and is tied to the specific number of prostheses sponsored by each company. The levy amount is set for a specific financial year, which is amended annually, as demonstrated by the upcoming 2025-26 amendments, following a cost review.
Over time, it has become apparent that this levy framework has faced issues, including a forward cost recovery method that disproportionately affected small companies, a lack of transparency in governance and financial expenditure, inadequate funding that was not keeping pace with cost pressures, and ambiguity in the scope of the prostheses list that led to complexity and potential double funding of some items. Our government agencies consulted with industries and stakeholders, and they provided feedback indicating that the levy calculation method based on billing codes on the prostheses list did not accurately reflect actual joint replacements or the cost to the registry. Without this change, the primary issue for insurers will be the inability to recover the costs of the NJRR as the legislation is needed to clarify who is responsible following changes in the medical device industry.
This amendment bill is designed to formalise and strengthen the framework governing the collection of the NJRR levy and is an important change. The central objective is to codify a clear legal basis for determining who is responsible for paying the levy, ensuring consistency with longstanding policy intent and addressing operational and legal uncertainties within the existing framework. A key feature of this bill is the creation of a 'person responsible' definition to be set out in rules, rather than in the primary legislation itself. Under the existing framework, the levy is imposed on medical device sponsors to fund the NJRR's post-market surveillance of joint replacement procedures, and this is very important given the longstanding lifespan of some of these devices.
We are modernising how the NJRR levy is administered, and this is a really great change. The adjustment in regulatory designs allows us, the government, to respond more effectively to evolving industry dynamics, to changes in the prostheses themselves and to changes in device sponsorship and company structure without requiring constant legislative amendment. It's about continuation of funding to preserve quality of care and services to allow flexibility and to improve patient care and really to make sure that we have a streamlined process of joint replacement surgery and follow-up of any perceived problems.
This legislation will affect our hospitals and our providers of prostheses, our surgeons in both the public and private health systems. The amendment ensures full cost recovery for the NJRR's operations, as well as supporting its role in quality improvements and data collection for joint replacement surgery. As we've said, we have over 80,000 joint replacements a year already. This is expected to increase significantly every year for a long period of time. This ensures that the levy system allows for cost recovery to the government and also improves health care. I commend the bill to the House. It is yet another sign of a government that understands health care. It's doing its best to cope with the enormous demands on the healthcare system in the 21st century and is providing equitable care to all Australians. I commend the bill to the House.
Tom French Moore, Australian Labor Party
6:28 pm
When Australians talk about health care, they talk about trust—trust that, when something goes wrong, the system is there and trust that, if your hip goes or your knee gives out, you won't be left behind because of your bank balance. It might sound technical, but it goes to the heart of trust in our healthcare system. When someone in my electorate of Moore gets a hip or knee replaced, they are putting their faith in a device and in the system that keeps that device safe. That system rests on one of Australia's quiet achievements: the National Joint Replacement Registry, or the NJRR.
The NJRR collects data from every hospital performing joint replacement surgery—hips, knees, shoulders, elbows, wrists, ankles and even spinal discs. It tells us what works, what fails and what lasts. It helps surgeons choose the best implants, and regulators remove poor performers. It is practical Australian ingenuity—data saving lives. And the funding mechanism that keeps it alive matters enormously. The Private Health Insurance (National Joint Replacement Register Levy) Amendment Bill 2025 keeps that funding certain, lawful and fair. It's a clean, precise amendment to fix a legal gap in the 2009 levy act, ensuring the right people pay—the companies responsible for the medical devices on the prescribed list, not hospitals or patients.
I'll now run through the detail. Schedule 1, part 1, 'Amendments', is the engine room. It replaces the outdated references to the 'sponsor' of a device with a clearer rule—the person specified in the rules made under section 8 pays the levy. That lets the minister, through the Private Health Insurance (Medical Devices and Human Tissue Products) Rules, define who precisely is liable: the company responsible at the time the levy is imposed. Items 1 to 3 tidy up definitions to match the renamed prescribed list rules and scrap redundant language. Together, these items modernise the law to match modern corporate reality, because companies merge, rebrand and sell their product lines, and the law needs to keep up. That's how you ensure cost recovery lands where it should—on those who profit, not those who heal. Item 4 locks that fairness in place.
Schedule 1, part 2, 'Application of amendments and validation of payment of certain levies', is equally vital. It confirms that the new definition applies going forward, and it validates past collections to remove any shadow of a doubt. Item 5 ensures that the new framework applies from commencement. Item 6 ensures that every levy already collected is deemed lawful. That protects the registry from legal challenge and keeps its funding stable. That's not paperwork. That's peace of mind, because the registry isn't a line item; it's a lifeline. Joondalup Health Campus in my electorate of Moore is one of WA's major orthopaedic surgery hubs. Hundreds of joint replacement operations take place there each year. Behind every operation is data—data that tells surgeons which prosthetics last 20 years and which ones fail after two. That evidence saves lives and limbs. Clause by clause, this bill keeps that quiet success story running.
Legislation always reveals values. Labor governments build systems that serve people. The Liberals let them rust while they argue and delay. This bill reflects the Labor instinct—fix the detail before it fails, and get the framework right so the system stays steady. That is how you govern for the long term. The opposition may just call it just technical. Tell that to a patient whose revision surgery was avoided because the registry flagged a fault in time. Tell that to the surgeon who didn't implant a defective device because the data was there. In healthy policy, the technicalities save lives. The NJRR was built by Labor, the levy framework was legislated by Labor, and this bill once again fixes the system Labor put in place to protect patients. We organise it, we fund it and we keep it lawful.
This bill also reflects consultation and fairness. The Department of Health and Aged Care consulted the Australian Orthopaedic Association and the Medical Technology Association of Australia. Surgeons supported the bill. Some manufacturers may grumble. No-one loves paying a levy, but fairness means everyone carries their share. If your company earns from devices implanted in Australians, you should help fund the system that helps keep them safe. That's the deal. Clause by clause, this bill re-anchors that principle. The person responsible for the device pays—not the patient, not the taxpayer and not the public hospital but the manufacturer, the supplier, the beneficiary of profit. That's cost recovery done right.
It's a small bill with a big moral centre. It says to Australians, 'Your government minds the details so you can trust the system.' It says, 'Your surgery will be safer because the data stays flowing.' It's the legislative equivalent of routine maintenance, invisible until the day you need it. Item 4 defines who pays, item 5 applies the rule and item 6 validates the path. Together they keep the registry funded, lawful and futureproof. That's what competent government looks like.
In my electorate, you see the impact. In Kingsley and Padbury, tradespeople rely on new knees to get back to work. In Duncraig and Carine, older Australians depend on strong hips to stay independent. In Mullaloo and Ocean Reef, grandparents want to walk grandkids to the beach. Those are the lives quietly improved by this bill, because when Canberra gets the detail wrong people pay for it in the suburbs. When the previous government ignored details, we got robodebt—a masterclass in arrogance that shattered lives. When they ignored accountability, we got a Prime Minister secretly swearing himself into multiple ministries. When they ignored maintenance, we got systems that broke and so people suffered. Labor governs differently. We fix the detail before it becomes a disaster.
Clause 5, the application provision, means the new rule applies from the day the amendment takes effect. From the next levy cycle onward, every company responsible for a listed device will pay properly—no confusion, no wiggle room, no legal gymnastics. It's certainty for business and stability for the registry. Clause 6, the validation clause, does something quietly powerful. It safeguards the public interest by ensuring every previous levy payment stands lawful. No-one can exploit a technical loophole to demand refunds or derail the registry. It tells industry that the rules are clear. It tells taxpayers that the system you've relied on remains solid. That's what good law looks like. It doesn't make headlines, but it makes hospitals work, it makes data flow, it makes surgery safer.
Some on the opposition benches may dismiss this as technical, but there is nothing boring about safer surgeries or laws that work as intended. Competence may not make headlines, but it saves lives. And we've seen what chaos looks like. For nine years, the Liberals were too busy fighting each other to fix the machinery of government. They left good programs half-written, reviews half-implemented, accountability half-existent. They had the registry, they had the levy and they had the chance to modernise it. And what did they do? Nothing. They left the gap sitting there, unfixed. They left the definition of 'sponsor' frozen in time while companies merged and the market moved on. They left regulators exposed to legal uncertainty. And now, as always, Labor is cleaning up the mess. This bill isn't glamorous, but it's vital. It says to patients, 'We've got your back.' It says to industry, 'Play fair and you'll have stability.' It says to regulators, 'The law now reflects reality.' That's modern government. It's not slogans and it's not scare campaigns, just steady delivery.
The explanatory memorandum notes that the passage is needed by 1 March 2026 to allow levy recovery in the 2025-26 financial year, so this parliament must act and act promptly. Delay would risk interrupting the funding base of one of the world's most successful health registries. Australia's population is ageing rapidly. By 2030, one in five Australians will be over 65, and demand for joint replacements will surge. These procedures are not elective luxuries. They restore independence, reduce falls and keep older Australians active in their communities. Every dollar spent keeping the registry strong is a dollar that prevents expensive revision surgeries later. This bill is forward planning, ensuring the cost-recovery model can sustain the registry as the need for data, transparency and safety grows. It's an investment in dignity as well as efficiency.
The NJRR isn't just an Australian success; it's a global model. Nations like Sweden, the UK and Canada have built their own systems on its example. Our registry's data helps surgeons everywhere improve their practice. That's something Australians can be proud of, a quiet export of expertise. The Australian Orthopaedic Association supports the bill. They know its value. The Medical Technology Association of Australia is less enthusiastic, because clarity brings accountability. But accountability is the price of trust. If you profit from devices inside Australians, you contribute to the system that keeps them safe. That's the social contract in practice. The bill fit squarely in Labor's philosophy of partnership. It complements the health minister's broader agenda—transparency, collaboration with clinicians and results over ideology. That's not radical, that's responsible.
This bill speaks to a personal truth for me. I stand here because of a kidney transplant. I know what it's like to rely on a health system that works, to trust that the data, the devices and the coordination all function when you need them most. When I read a bill like this, I don't see bureaucracy. I see reassurance—reassurance that the system that saved me is being kept strong for others. That's why I take so-called technical bills seriously, because they are anything but.
Australians expect their governments to mind the store. They expect competence, clarity and care. That's exactly what this bill delivers. It might never make the nightly news, but it will make for safer surgeries, stronger hospitals and steadier trust. In Moore, that means people recovering faster. It means fewer revision surgeries at Joondalup Health Campus. It means more grandparents back on their feet, more workers back on the job and more confidence in Medicare's wider system of care. That's good government. It's the difference between noise and results, slogans and systems, politics and progress. The opposition had nine years to fix this and didn't. Labor saw a gap and fixed it in one. That's the story of Australian politics in miniature. We build; they bluster.
Let me finish where I began, with trust. Trust in our health system is not automatic. It is earned through decades of quiet, careful work. It's preserved by governments that take the responsibility seriously. It is embodied in bills like this one—precise, purposeful and practical. So when Australians in Moore or anywhere else go in for surgery they can do so knowing their government has done its job, that the registry monitoring their implants is funded, lawful and future proofed, that the companies profiting from medical devices are paying their fair share and that the system behind the scenes is working as it should. It reminds us why Labor governs the way it does, with attention to detail, respect for expertise and faith in collective care. It's because that's the foundation of a modern, fair nation. It's a government that notices the small things so citizens can dream about the big ones. That's good policy, that's good government, and that's the Labor difference. I commend the bill to the House.
Question agreed to.
Bill read a second time.