House debates Bills

Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024; Second Reading

Thursday, 28 November 2024 House of Representatives

Kate Chaney

Kate Chaney Curtin, Independent

1:11 pm

In March this year, I moved a private member's motion calling on the government to increase Australia's international competitiveness for new energy industries, specifically by introducing production tax incentives. This motion was part of a long list of speeches and representations I've made, urging the government for a bold response to the United States Inflation Reduction Act.

I've been worried that Australia is not acting fast enough or decisively enough to take advantage of the global transition to green energy. Today, I'm pleased to rise in support of the government's introduction of production tax incentives for hydrogen and critical minerals, which will support Australian industry in an increasingly competitive international market. I want to talk about why we need incentives like these, why production tax incentives are the way to go and what it means for the future of and critical minerals for Australia—specifically, WA.

With decarbonisation, the global economy is shifting. After a transitional period, different countries will emerge as winners and losers, depending on their natural advantages and how nimbly they've responded to new opportunities. There's much discussion about Australia's natural advantages in a net zero global economy: our abundance of sun, wind and critical minerals. For example, Australia is one of the few countries in the world with all of the input minerals and materials required for lithium batteries. But we face a very real risk of remaining a country that digs and ships, rather than being a serious and competitive producer of new energy, unless we make sure that downstream processing projects are established onshore.

We also need to build a more resilient and diversified economy, one that will not only thrive in a decarbonised world but also withstand shocks and financial disruptions, like those we suffered during the COVID-19 pandemic and, following that, the wars in Ukraine and the Middle East. Right now, Australia has poor economic complexity. Our economic complexity ranking has dropped 27 places since 2007. We rank 93 out of 133 countries, between Uganda and Pakistan. For comparison, some of the countries we normally see as our peers include Japan, which ranked first; the UK, eighth; and the US, 14th. According to Harvard's Atlas of Economic Complexity, Australia's low result is due to a lack of diversification of exports. If we want a strong, stable and prosperous economy, we need to diversify into decarbonised industries and production of more complex products that the world wants.

The Inflation Reduction Act broke new ground with its A$1 trillion commitment to green and renewable energy. It was the most significant climate legislation in US history. Approximately two-thirds of this IRA budget is allocated to uncapped tax incentives for different stages of production within clean energy industries. These tax incentives deliver a deafeningly loud signal to investors that are considering doing new energy business in the US. While we don't know exactly what the future is for the US Inflation Reduction Act post-Trump, it is clear the race is on for countries to position themselves as leaders in the new energy economy. If President Trump does roll back some of the IRA incentives, it could actually be the opportunity we need to catch up.

Investors are looking for reasons to choose Australia over other countries. Companies are actively looking to develop and grow their renewables operations in Australia, but they need this government to give them tangible confirmation of Australia's energy transition vision and give them the confidence and certainty that Australia will welcome and incentive the new energy opportunities currently knocking on our door.

In the US, the manufacturing of batteries, solar panels and wind turbines, as well as the processing of critical minerals, attracts production tax incentives, as well as further bonus tax credits for components made in the US. The US package also has committed tax credits for any investments in zero emissions electricity generation facilities or energy storage technology.

The Smart Energy Council here in Australia has reported that, due to the attractive US incentives, many of its member companies are moving their facilities to the US or proactively considering how to access IRA incentives. With Australian production costs already 10 per cent higher than the US, it's essential that the government provides a clear signal that Australia is ready and willing to invest in value-adding downstream projects. We have all the natural resources for this to make sense, but, if other countries beat us to build the infrastructure, it will be too late.

Production tax incentives are a proven mechanism that means you pay less tax when you actually produce something. The way productive tax incentives usual work is to attach the credit to phases of manufacturing and production for a set period. Independent research from Mandala Partners found that the key driver for financial close for downstream projects is incentives that help mitigate total operating costs throughout production cycles—not loans and not upfront grants but long-term embedded incentives that encourage advantages and production. Instead of money paid upfront for something that may or may not become tangible, production tax incentives are payable only when you deliver, so taxpayers are paying for results.

The hydrogen production tax incentive in this bill is intended to bring forward project development, make renewable hydrogen available sooner and build scale to reduce production costs over time. It will be delivered through Australia's tax system as a refundable tax offset providing a $2 per kilogram incentive for renewable hydrogen to eligible producers for up to 10 years, finishing in 2040. The CSIRO recognises that green hydrogen is likely to play a significant role in a net zero global energy economy, with the potential to avoid approximately one-third of Australia's current fossil fuel emissions by 2050.

Under the government's National Hydrogen Strategy, published earlier this year, green hydrogen manufactured in upcoming hydrogen hubs operating with reduced production costs will complement other renewable energy sources identified under the climate change bill. But hydrogen still faces significant hurdles. Its current high production costs, at $5 to $6 per kilogram, must fall to about $2 per kilogram in order to become commercially viable. This should happen over time with technological innovation and renewable prices decreasing. For many hard to abate industries like steelmaking, shipping and aviation, hydrogen is the most promising prospect for decarbonisation, but it's not yet competitively priced. This production tax incentive for hydrogen is a step in the right direction. Ultimately, hydrogen will get there, but we need to make sure we are in the race by the time it does. Many other countries are competing to be leaders in hydrogen.

Critical minerals such as lithium, nickel, cobalt, silicon and rare earth elements are essential components in many rapidly growing clean energy technologies. They're critical because they can't be easily or cost effectively substituted. This bill targets critical minerals by introducing the CMPTI, with eligible entities able to claim up to 10 per cent of their eligible expenditure for the processing and refining of critical minerals for a maximum 10-year period. This will be delivered in the form of a refundable offset similar to that proposed to hydrogen. Analysis by Mandala Partners estimates that the economic benefit of supported downstream processing of critical minerals could represent up to $2.4 billion in Australia's economy by 2035.

Western Australia, my home state, accounts for around half of global lithium production and is a major exporter of nickel, cobalt, manganese and rare-earth elements. This government has already put nickel on the official Critical Minerals List and in February announced a 50 per cent royalty discount for 18 months, to address serious competition in that market, which was a positive step. It's essential that we accelerate opportunities in WA's critical minerals sector and capitalise now on the position that critical and battery minerals will play in decarbonising the global economy.

The final component of this legislation affords Indigenous Business Australia greater powers to borrow and raise money by reducing barriers on investment partners, both Commonwealth and private. This modernisation of IBA's borrowing powers provides flexibility so that IBA can play a bigger role in supporting and promoting First Nations economic self-determination.

The Joint Standing Committee on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs, of which I'm a member, recently concluded our inquiry into economic self-determination and opportunities for First Nations Australians. Recommendation 8 of that report, which was tabled yesterday, was:

… that the Australian Government strengthen existing, and develop new, instruments to enhance and fast track Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples' access to finance and capital.

I commend the government's responsiveness to the joint standing committee regarding this matter, as a first step.

Before I conclude, I would like to make a comment about the Leader of the Opposition's stance on this bill. When the production tax incentives were announced in the budget, the Leader of the Opposition went running to the media, declaring that the incentives were 'tax cuts for billionaires' and vowing to repeal the bill if elected. This statement put him at odds with the WA Liberal Party. The WA Liberals are in favour of this bill because it's good for WA. I'm baffled as to how the Leader of the Opposition, who purports to be a champion of business and good economic management, would oppose an incentive that's designed to increase investment and innovation in Australia. Funding production tax incentives for critical minerals and hydrogen will be good for WA, as we encourage investment and add value and green energy to our natural resources, and, by extension, that's also good for Australia.

In conclusion, I'm pleased to see a production tax incentives approach taken here. It means incentives are only paid once something is produced, it gives certainty to emerging industries, it ensures that we can make the most of our natural resources and it positions us as a long-term leader in a net zero economy. I commend the bill to the House.

Aaron Violi

Aaron Violi Casey, Liberal Party

1:22 pm

This bill, the Future Made in Australia (Production Tax Credits and Other Measures) Bill 2024, like so many of the government's bills, follows the standard procedure. It's just like, 'It must be another day that ends in Y—we've got a bill with a really impressive name.' Of course everyone backs a future made in Australia, but, when you look at the detail, it doesn't stack up.

This bill also highlights one of the fatal flaws of the Albanese Labor government. The Albanese Labor government are obsessed with picking winners—picking their favourites, like PsiQuantum, the Silicon Valley based company which they put under the Future Made in Australia banner—instead of focusing on raising all boats with a rising tide and making decisions to get the key economic indicators right. They're focused on tax credits in the 2030s, which probably won't even make a difference. Let's chat to Twiggy Forrest about that; he's pulling out of green hydrogen.

When they focus on this issue of picking winners and they're distracted, there are real-world consequences. I want to share a letter from Cathy at Discovery Community Care in my community. She wrote to me, so frustrated with this government. I want to read her words, as they need to be heard: 'Towards the end of 2023, we noticed a significant shift in those reaching out for food support. It was no longer only those who were unemployed or experiencing homelessness or struggling with mental health challenges. The biggest demographic shift was now those working. But they cannot make ends meet. The 'working poor' category has been the biggest growth demographic for us in 2024. We are now helping more families, whereas, historically, our households may have represented predominantly singles or smaller households. We now have, on average, a hundred people walking through our doors each week, which equates to 586 people in households. We have grown by 400 per cent since March 2024. The recent funding offered by the government for food relief has landed with OzHarvest, SecondBite and the large organisations, which I'm sure they need also. However, the organisations at the grassroots level, who are at the coalface, interacting with the people, putting food on the tables for families and giving hundreds of thousands of unpaid hours to make this possible, also need funding that doesn't require us to jump through hoops and give copious hours to do so, only to often be overlooked for the bigger activities when we are already time poor.' This is an example of the struggles of my community, which the Treasurer and the Prime Minister seem immune to. They're focused on tax credits and anything but helping the Australian people.

To make it worse for Cathy and our community, the program of government funding that she referred to was $14 million that the government put out into the community to help those in need, and, when we look at the priorities of the government, we see that, at exactly the same time that they committed that $14 million, they also committed $40 million to sell the stage 3 tax cuts—$40 million to sell something that didn't need to be sold, and $14 million to help food relief centres. I wonder and worry, as they rush this bill through today, about how much they are going to spend to sell these Future Made in Australia production tax credits, which are not going to help anyone in Casey or make any difference to the challenges the Australian people face.

When we understand everything under the Future Made in Australia banner and we look at it holistically, there is an important point we need to understand: it's picking winners. I mentioned PsiQuantum, and I want to again talk about PsiQuantum as an example and talk about the process that PsiQuantum went through, because the Australian people need to understand that every part of the flawed process undertaken in relation to PsiQuantum, one of the first projects under this Future Made in Australia banner, has a cloud over it.

We know that Minister Husic picked his favourite. He was sold on PsiQuantum in early 2023. He was so sold on it and had so much confidence that he clearly gave agreements to PsiQuantum that they were going to get the money that they required, because PsiQuantum were out in the investor community sending emails and confirming their advanced negotiations with the Australian government. They were talking to venture capitalists and other investors, trying to get more money for PsiQuantum off the back of the agreement and the advanced negotiations they had with the Australian people. There's a big problem with the timing of this. They were telling people in July of 2023 about the advanced negotiations and agreement they had. The problem for the minister, which he has still not addressed, is that the independent EOI process that he loves to talk about actually started in August of 2023. So we've got taxpayer money, all under the Future Made in Australia banner, which really should be rebranded 'future made in Silicon Valley', because that's where the head office of PsiQuantum is. PsiQuantum were telling people, 'We've got money,' before a supposedly independent EOI process was underway.

So how can the Australian people trust anything this government says when it comes to Future Made in Australia? They can't. This is the problem. The outcome is predetermined. Lobbyists were lining up to see the Minister for Industry and Science and the Treasurer to get their support, because, if you get the support of the government, you get the red carpet, and, if you're a business trying to go about your best life to create economic opportunities for your community, you're abandoned.

But it's even better than that. The Prime Minister, when asked about it, said:

There's first mover advantage in areas such as this and Australia can't afford to sit back and watch other countries get ahead of us in an area where we have this enormous opportunity.

The problem with that for the Prime Minister is that, at the same time that we gave a billion dollars of taxpayer money, the US state of Illinois gave PsiQuantum $760 million to build the same computer in the state of Illinois, in Chicago, so we're not even getting the first-mover advantage. It feels very much like the Simpsons episode with the monorail. They sold the monorail to the community as a great opportunity. Minister Husic got sold on the monorail from PsiQuantum. He disregarded process. He disregarded taxpayer money. He went all in on this one company, and it completely undermines the process of any bill under Future Made in Australia, because how do we know that other organisations have not been able to lobby successfully? How do we know, for those industries that are going to get these tax credits, what work they have done—

Ian Goodenough

Ian Goodenough Moore, Liberal Party

Order! It being 1.30 pm, the debate is interrupted in accordance with standing order 43. The debate may be resumed at a later hour.