House debates Questions without Notice

Prime Minister

Wednesday, 2 December 2020 House of Representatives

Richard Marles

Richard Marles Corio, Australian Labor Party, Shadow Minister for Defence

2:30 pm

My question is to the Treasurer as Minister representing the Minister for Finance, who is responsible for Commonwealth assets, including The Lodge. Can the Treasurer confirm that the Prime Minister is spending 14 days in quarantine with his photographer but not the head of his department, not his chief of staff, not his senior health or economic advisers and not his national security adviser? Why is the Prime Minister always focused on photo ops and marketing?

Tony Smith

Tony Smith Speaker

I call the Leader of the House.

Christian Porter

Christian Porter Pearce, Liberal Party, Attorney-General

As well as there being a number of detectable inaccuracies there, even using the fact that the Treasurer represents the Minister for Finance, that could hardly be said to be—

Opposition members interjecting—

Tony Smith

Tony Smith Speaker

Could the Leader of the House pause for a second. Could the members on my left cease interjecting. Leader of the House, if you could just rewind back a sentence, that would be helpful.

Christian Porter

Christian Porter Pearce, Liberal Party, Attorney-General

I'll do that, absolutely. Even allowing for the fact that the Treasurer represents the Minister for Finance in this House, the fact of personnel being in The Lodge—of which there are a number, as would necessarily be the case, to support the Prime Minister—and who exactly they are could hardly be said to be inside the responsibility or the officially connected public affairs of the Minister for Finance.

Dr Aly interjecting—

Tony Smith

Tony Smith Speaker

The member for Cowan is warned. I just say to those members interjecting that I can arrange a third chamber for them, separate to the Federation Chamber, out in the opposition lobby. I take the point that the Leader of the House made. Only the first part of the question, asking the Treasurer to confirm that the Prime Minister was spending 14 days in quarantine, is in order; the rest isn't. The fact that the answer's obvious doesn't mean it's not in order. We can see the Prime Minister there in quarantine. If the Treasurer wants to address himself to the bleedingly obvious, he can, but the rest of the question is not in order.

Josh Frydenberg

Josh Frydenberg Kooyong, Liberal Party, Treasurer

2:32 pm

As the House is aware, the Prime Minister undertook an important visit to Japan on behalf of this nation where significant agreements were signed and where Australia's interests were advanced. One would think, at a time of an increasingly complex strategic environment, that the Prime Minister of this country becoming the first foreign leader to be invited to Japan to meet with Prime Minister Suga is a very significant reflection on the positive bilateral relationship between Australia and Japan. So I'd say to those opposite that, instead of making a mockery of an important visit on behalf of this nation, they should understand the significance of Australia's bilateral relationship with Japan, which has been advanced by our Prime Minister's historic visit only weeks ago.