House debates Questions without Notice

Deputy Prime Minister

Thursday, 15 February 2018 House of Representatives

Mark Dreyfus

Mark Dreyfus Isaacs, Australian Labor Party, Shadow Attorney General

2:42 pm

My question is to the Deputy Prime Minister, and I refer to his previous answers. Isn't it the case that, because of the decisions of the Deputy Prime Minister, Mr Maguire had at least $5,000 of taxpayers' money in his pocket when he gave the Deputy Prime Minister free accommodation?

Tony Smith

Tony Smith Speaker

The Deputy Prime Minister can address the question. I don't like the description that's in it because it implies that the recipient received money not in a business way, and we dealt with that before in other contexts. I really don't like that.

An honourable member: He could rephrase it.

In fact, that's right—I think it should be rephrased. Or I can rule it out of order. I call the member for Isaacs.

Mark Dreyfus

Mark Dreyfus Isaacs, Australian Labor Party, Shadow Attorney General

I'll ask the whole question again, Mr Speaker. My question is to the Deputy Prime Minister, and I refer to his previous answers. Isn't it the case that, because of the decisions of the Deputy Prime Minister, Mr Maguire had received at least $5,000 of taxpayers' money when he gave the Deputy Prime Minister free accommodation?

Tony Smith

Tony Smith Speaker

Before I call the Leader of the House, now that I've heard the question again, the bit that grated with me is not the major problem, which was why I did want to hear it again and pause. That is an imputation of an improper motive, and I think that's very clearly out of order under the standing orders.