House debates Personal Explanations

Wednesday, 26 June 2013 House of Representatives

Bernie Ripoll

Bernie Ripoll Oxley, Australian Labor Party, Parliamentary Secretary for Small Business

3:55 pm

I wish to make a personal explanation.

Bruce Scott

Bruce Scott Deputy-Speaker

Does the honourable member claim to have been misrepresented?

Bernie Ripoll

Bernie Ripoll Oxley, Australian Labor Party, Parliamentary Secretary for Small Business

Yes.

Bruce Scott

Bruce Scott Deputy-Speaker

Please proceed.

Bernie Ripoll

Bernie Ripoll Oxley, Australian Labor Party, Parliamentary Secretary for Small Business

During question time today I was misrepresented by the shadow small minister for business.

Bruce Scott

Bruce Scott Deputy-Speaker

Order! Come on, member for Oxley. It is the shadow minister for small business.

Bernie Ripoll

Bernie Ripoll Oxley, Australian Labor Party, Parliamentary Secretary for Small Business

He misquoted me.

Bruce Scott

Bruce Scott Deputy-Speaker

Member for Oxley, I think you might look at the phrasing of your description of the small minister.

Bernie Ripoll

Bernie Ripoll Oxley, Australian Labor Party, Parliamentary Secretary for Small Business

That was what I was hoping for from the shadow minister. He said that in a speech that I made I said that small businesses do not pay the carbon price.

Bruce Scott

Bruce Scott Deputy-Speaker

I have asked the parliamentary secretary to correct, for the record, the description of who he said he was misrepresented by.

Bernie Ripoll

Bernie Ripoll Oxley, Australian Labor Party, Parliamentary Secretary for Small Business

By the shadow minister.

Bernie Ripoll

Bernie Ripoll Oxley, Australian Labor Party, Parliamentary Secretary for Small Business

For small business.

Opposition members interjecting

Bruce Scott

Bruce Scott Deputy-Speaker

I thank the parliamentary secretary.

Bernie Ripoll

Bernie Ripoll Oxley, Australian Labor Party, Parliamentary Secretary for Small Business

Almost as big as the shadow minister.

Bruce Scott

Bruce Scott Deputy-Speaker

Member for Oxley, you have the call to show where you have been misrepresented.

Bernie Ripoll

Bernie Ripoll Oxley, Australian Labor Party, Parliamentary Secretary for Small Business

I quoted that small business do not pay the carbon price. In fact, what I said was that small businesses do not pay the carbon price. It is a price paid by Australia's biggest polluters.