House debates Personal Explanations

Tuesday, 26 May 2009 House of Representatives

Wilson Tuckey

Wilson Tuckey O'Connor, Liberal Party

3:46 pm

Mr Speaker, I seek to make a personal explanation.

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

Does the member claim to have been misrepresented?

Wilson Tuckey

Wilson Tuckey O'Connor, Liberal Party

Grievously so, Mr Speaker.

Wilson Tuckey

Wilson Tuckey O'Connor, Liberal Party

During question time, the PM inferred that I had offered—by my enforced silence at that moment—that I had no criticism of his education cash splash in my electorate. I refer the House to yesterday’s Proof Hansard, in which I said:

Then there are school buildings. There is the government’s—

that is, the Howard government’s—

$1.2 billion Investing in Our Schools Program, which was funded with cash and gave school principals and local parents groups the opportunity to spend up to $150,000 on buildings or equipment.

I went on to say:

Very few schools in my electorate applied for the full amount of $150,000, although some could have wisely spent more. But this budget forces them to take another $200,000. It is like feeding a pate goose: you have it forced down your throat whether you need it or not … But is it going to improve the education of the children—

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

Order! The member has explained where he has been misrepresented—

Wilson Tuckey

Wilson Tuckey O'Connor, Liberal Party

No, sir. The other comment I made related to spending that money on the training of teachers and it is no good having schools built. In other words, I have made a public comment on this and I stand by it.

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

Order! The member has explained where he has been misrepresented and I thank him for doing it by the processes—

Unidentified interjection - Hansard doesn't record who said this

Honourable Members:

Honourable members interjecting—

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

Order! I thought that there might be, but I just want to put on record—and the member should sit down and just settle down a little bit—that he has taken the opportunities that are available to him when aggrieved with things that are said, or rhetorical questions are put to him. He has shown the way to deal with it. I thank him for that.

Wilson Tuckey

Wilson Tuckey O'Connor, Liberal Party

I wish now to make a further personal explanation.

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

Does the member for O’Connor claim to have been further misrepresented?

Wilson Tuckey

Wilson Tuckey O'Connor, Liberal Party

I do.

Wilson Tuckey

Wilson Tuckey O'Connor, Liberal Party

The Minister for Health and Ageing suggested that a program that cancelled waiting lists and saved the people a third of the cost of Medicare was some sort of dumb exercise. It was very smart. It was rejected by the—

Harry Jenkins

Harry Jenkins Speaker

Order! The member for O’Connor will resume his seat. Having been given an A for his first effort, that was nearly a fail, but he has made his point.